Live data from Hacker News

Tragically, as many as 9625 out of every 10k individuals may be neurotypical

erikengdahl.se

11–20 of 134 posts

Re: Tragically, as many as 9625 out of every 10k individuals may be neurotypical

#11
post #9

Is there value to people constantly self-diagnosing themselves or seeking clinical diagnoses for neurodivergency? I don't mean this in a disparaging way; but surely constantly seeking to remind both yourself and society of your neurodivergency and any shortcomings you have with that seems almost like a crab bucket mentality that you are enveloping yourself with. I don't have a problem with people looking inwards, but…

Why do you think this person is self diagnosed?

Re: Tragically, as many as 9625 out of every 10k individuals may be neurotypical

#13

I sometimes wonder if there are other possible neurodivergence, I'm not neurotypical, but I'm also not autistic (at least according to the criteria I've seen), just a bit odd or quirky doesn't seem to be enough.

Neurodivergent is absolutely not a synonym for autistic.

https://sherlocksflataffect.tumblr.com/post/121295972384/psa...

https://neuroqueer.com/neurodiversity-terms-and-definitions/

Re: Tragically, as many as 9625 out of every 10k individuals may be neurotypical

#14
post #9

Is there value to people constantly self-diagnosing themselves or seeking clinical diagnoses for neurodivergency? I don't mean this in a disparaging way; but surely constantly seeking to remind both yourself and society of your neurodivergency and any shortcomings you have with that seems almost like a crab bucket mentality that you are enveloping yourself with. I don't have a problem with people looking inwards, but…

Neurodivergence does not require a diagnosis. https://sherlocksflataffect.tumblr.com/post/121295972384/psa...

And looking outwards is exactly what it does since it references societal neuronormativity. It’s not about the “shortcomings you have”.

Re: Tragically, as many as 9625 out of every 10k individuals may be neurotypical

#15

I sometimes wonder if there are other possible neurodivergence, I'm not neurotypical, but I'm also not autistic (at least according to the criteria I've seen), just a bit odd or quirky doesn't seem to be enough.

ADHD, OCD, BPD, bipolar are all forms of neurodivergent. I'm sure there are more too.

Re: Tragically, as many as 9625 out of every 10k individuals may be neurotypical

#16
post #9

Is there value to people constantly self-diagnosing themselves or seeking clinical diagnoses for neurodivergency? I don't mean this in a disparaging way; but surely constantly seeking to remind both yourself and society of your neurodivergency and any shortcomings you have with that seems almost like a crab bucket mentality that you are enveloping yourself with. I don't have a problem with people looking inwards, but…

Neurodivergence does not require a diagnosis. https://sherlocksflataffect.tumblr.com/post/121295972384/psa... And looking outwards is exactly what it does since it references societal neuronormativity. It’s not about the “shortcomings you have”.

If you're looking outwards merely just to look inwards again, then you're missing the point of what I'm trying to say.

Re: Tragically, as many as 9625 out of every 10k individuals may be neurotypical

#17
The neurodivergent label was always incredibly stupid though. It's an entire movement trying to make it sound that having a pathological condition is fashionable. Something like a super quirky, human difference, as opposed to a health problem. Even though the condition is defined in the context of reduced functioning in society. OPs site is a good example of that flawed line of thinking.

The bigger issue is that the various illnesses under the "neurodivergent" umbrella have wide differences in impact. So you might get people who function in society and others who can't do anything. The former of which wants to make it some quirky personality trait. They both still have the condition though...

Re: Tragically, as many as 9625 out of every 10k individuals may be neurotypical

#18
post #9

Is there value to people constantly self-diagnosing themselves or seeking clinical diagnoses for neurodivergency? I don't mean this in a disparaging way; but surely constantly seeking to remind both yourself and society of your neurodivergency and any shortcomings you have with that seems almost like a crab bucket mentality that you are enveloping yourself with. I don't have a problem with people looking inwards, but…

Some can be improved with meditation. For example there is a roughly 60% comorbidity of ASD and ADHD and the ADHD portion can be improved with certain nonstimulant medications. Another example is that some disorders like psychosis and schizophrenia could pose harm that demands intervention.

Re: Tragically, as many as 9625 out of every 10k individuals may be neurotypical

#19

> written by some "expert" from the perspective that neurotypical perception is correct, and my brain is a genetic mistake. Well, it is a mistake. It is a deviation from the normal path. But so what? "Correct" and "mistake" are not antonyms. Without any mistakes, there would no be life in the world as we know. This is not a moral codemnation of any individual. > I and my experience of life is not inferior, and may be…

> Well, it is a mistake.

If you say it is a mistake, then you must know what the goal is.

Post reply on HN