Live data from Hacker News

America's Military Is Dangerously Exposed

wsj.com

11–13 of 13 posts

Re: America's Military Is Dangerously Exposed

#11
Our military is now a multi trillion dollar per year corruption albatross that will bankrupt US.

The managerial design of the military can't even pivot to cheap drone systems: there is no military career in such prosaic, low-budget items, no cushy jobs (ahem bribes) in such weapons system manufacture.

And yet drones now have demonstrated that with a dirt cheap military expenditure you can make the prospect of land invasion of your country by the United States impossible, because the tolerance for the 10,000s of casualties that will result are politically untenable even for a all-three-branch dominant cult of personality president like Trump.

On top of that, the US now is dangerously dependent on vastly expanded trade supply lines in a world where drone technology has now fundamentally compromised the security of world shipping. I'm not even talking about Iran in the Hormuz Strait, piddy dirt poor Yemen is now shutting down the Red Sea/Suez.

To proceed the US needs to do the following:

- invest vast sums (like, say the utterly worthless military budget we have now) in alternative energy and electrified/hybrid transportation to fundamentally eliminate the strategic significance of the Middle East, and destroy the political influence of global petroleum companies

- invest even more vast sums in onshoring / nearshoring manufacturing in North and South America, and vastly increase American domestic manufacturing

- obviously we need a massive sea change in drone adoption and technology in the armed forces... that does not however require vast sums, just willpower and a fundamental reprioritization of the military industrial complex

Where is the budget for all of these? Well, it's in the existing dinosaur military budget. Our Navy is only good for deep water interdiction, it can no longer approach within 100 miles of hostile shores. The Army and Marines are completely useless at ground operations and would get slaughtered by any country with reasonable drone capability. The Air force can continue to bomb, but it is fundamentally a losing economic proposition, and it can no longer pave the way for a ground invasion.

Re: America's Military Is Dangerously Exposed

#12
post #3

You were warned they'd do this. They did it. Maybe don't elect them if you don't want the outcome.

Human error. One of our teams deployed a bug to prod. The methods in place to remediate the bug are not sufficient, and we have to wait until next release to get it patched. Unless the bug is actually malware, in which case we can only hope the malware doesn’t overwrite the SOP for next release and stay in the system somehow. We are having troubles getting all teams in agreement due to poor architecture of the system. We have to do a rewrite of some major components if we want to prevent the issue in the future. Starting to feel like a lost cause though, as we can’t seem to come to an agreement on what the standards should be in any area. Unfortunately this is a system that does handle lives, and we simply do not have enough properly experienced and educated people to work on these issues with the budget to fight the existing system. Expect more lives to be lost and time-delayed problems in the future.

Re: America's Military Is Dangerously Exposed

#13
post #7

It’s time for US to get out of the Middle East, period.

that will happen… exactly never. The empire of the United States will collapse before that happens (which will happen as all empires fall and we are not different)

I don't see how it can not happen at this point. Iran won the war and has shown everyone that the US can't even protect itself in the region let alone the Gulf states.

The bases, radar installations, supply depots, airfields, and so on, that took decades and untold trillions to build are all gone now, and US forces have been pushed back all the way to Jordan already. The satellite data shows the scale of the destruction pretty clearly.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-07-25/us-military-damage-to...

There's no coming back from this. The US is basically blind now without all the early detection systems, and missile inventories are largely empty too. On top of that, the US can't even produce rare earths or magnets on its own.

https://theoregongroup.com/commodities/rare-earths/us-suppli...

Without that, you can't even build a lot of these advanced weapons. Meanwhile, AP reports that nearly 700 U.S. service members have been wounded by drone and missile attacks on bases in the Middle East and other fighting. Given that the Pentagon is covering real numbers up, the reality is likely far worse.

https://apnews.com/article/iran-war-traumatic-brain-injuries...

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2026/jul/...

This is a total military defeat for the US, and on top of that there are Hormuz and Bab el-Mandeb closures which are disrupting global energy markets. The US has been trying to stabilize oil prices by releasing the reserves, but those are starting to run dry.

https://www.cnbc.com/2026/08/10/oil-in-strategic-petroleum-r...

An economic crash is a very likely scenario once it's no longer possible to release reserve to push oil prices down. At that point, it's simply not gonna be possible to keep a presence in the Gulf.

Post reply on HN