Live data from Hacker News

Anyone else get a vague GitHub shakedown notice?

lists.osgeo.org

11–20 of 51 posts

Re: Anyone else get a vague GitHub shakedown notice?

#11
post #5

What about this email is a "shakedown"?

The part where it says they are about to start taking your money?

Sending a billing notification to someone who has no billing information on file, but is part of an organization where someone probably enabled that beta feature ("You're receiving this because your organization is using the GitHub Code Quality public preview.") isn't a shakedown.

Re: Anyone else get a vague GitHub shakedown notice?

#13

I got the same email, and I don't have a credit card on file with them. I wonder what they're going to do?

Is this really the normal way to do this in the US? Does no billing info mean you’re immune? If they have your real name in Germany, they would just send it to collections and get their money if you really owe them something, even if they don’t have a way to charge it directly themselves.

Re: Anyone else get a vague GitHub shakedown notice?

#14
post #9

This links to this, which says https://docs.github.com/en/code-security/concepts/about-code... > GitHub Code Quality is currently in public preview and will become generally available on July 20, 2026. During public preview, Code Quality scans will consume GitHub Actions minutes but you will not be billed for other usage. From July 20, 2026, usage will incur additional charges. See GitHub Code Quality billing. >If yo…

It's probably now called CoPilot Code CoPilot Quality CoPilot™. Do you see that anywhere in your settings?

Re: Anyone else get a vague GitHub shakedown notice?

#15

No, I didn't, because I quit GitHub when they started demanding mandatory SMS 2FA

> No, I didn't, because I quit GitHub when they started demanding mandatory SMS 2FA

They haven't demanded that of me. I have 2FA with a Yubikey and a TOTP app.

I don't ever recall giving them my phone number.

Re: Anyone else get a vague GitHub shakedown notice?

#16
I'm a GitHub admin. Did not receive this e-mail. We don't have the GitHub Code Quality feature enabled anywhere, though.

The e-mail seems clear: Someone enabled the feature in the organization. The feature was in free preview, but the free preview is ending. If they leave it enabled, it will be billed at the new rate.

It's pretty clear that "organization" is being used throughout the e-mail, so they're not referring to this person's free personal GitHub account.

Re: Anyone else get a vague GitHub shakedown notice?

#17

I got the same email, and I don't have a credit card on file with them. I wonder what they're going to do?

Is this really the normal way to do this in the US? Does no billing info mean you’re immune? If they have your real name in Germany, they would just send it to collections and get their money if you really owe them something, even if they don’t have a way to charge it directly themselves.

Yeah, as far as I know. Also github doesn't have my real name, for instance. I am sure they could know it, but I never agreed to any billing, either.

Re: Anyone else get a vague GitHub shakedown notice?

#18

I got the same email, and I don't have a credit card on file with them. I wonder what they're going to do?

Is this really the normal way to do this in the US? Does no billing info mean you’re immune? If they have your real name in Germany, they would just send it to collections and get their money if you really owe them something, even if they don’t have a way to charge it directly themselves.

Generally yes, though I remember seeing a post on hacker news in the past month where a SAAS sent an invoice after the free trial ended rather than terminating it.

I always expect a failed billing or no billing info after a trial to cancel and not be pursued (I regularly do trials with a temp card that I immediately de-activate so it cannot be billed in case I forget to cancel)

Re: Anyone else get a vague GitHub shakedown notice?

#19
post #9

This links to this, which says https://docs.github.com/en/code-security/concepts/about-code... > GitHub Code Quality is currently in public preview and will become generally available on July 20, 2026. During public preview, Code Quality scans will consume GitHub Actions minutes but you will not be billed for other usage. From July 20, 2026, usage will incur additional charges. See GitHub Code Quality billing. >If yo…

> I don't see that tab, so either the docs are out of date, and it's called something else now, or it's not on all accounts/all repos.

Correct. It's only for certain plans like GitHub Team and Enterprise Cloud.

The weird part about this e-mail is that they said they recently left some organizations because "the tone of the paid services" increased. So either they're still a member of one of these organizations, or GitHub mistakenly sent the e-mail to past members?

Re: Anyone else get a vague GitHub shakedown notice?

#20

I got the same email, and I don't have a credit card on file with them. I wonder what they're going to do?

Is this really the normal way to do this in the US? Does no billing info mean you’re immune? If they have your real name in Germany, they would just send it to collections and get their money if you really owe them something, even if they don’t have a way to charge it directly themselves.

For the vast majority of services, yes
Post reply on HN