Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Like a Bouncer at a Bookstore: Texas' App Store Accountability Act

cdt.org

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–17 of 17 posts

Re: Like a Bouncer at a Bookstore: Texas' App Store Accountability Act

#11

Post by Cider9986 »

_aavaa_ wrote: post #10
Cider9986 wrote: post #5

This law is terrible and I hope it isn't implemented, but it's enabled by the locked down and centralized nature of iOS and the way most people get apps on Android, the Play store. Once you try Android, you can't go back. I used an iPhone all my life, but a few months ago I switched to GrapheneOS and the FOSS software ecosystem is fantastic. On iPhones, if a government doesn't want an app, like those ICE tracking app…

That’s great for Kia, but if I owned at VW it doesn’t do me much good. Same problem with banking apps.

My point was that more apps practicing this security theatre are adding compatibility for GrapheneOS because it's rapidly growing in users.

Re: Like a Bouncer at a Bookstore: Texas' App Store Accountability Act

#13

Post by dlcarrier »

mcphage wrote: post #9

I don’t mind Apple’s walled garden in the abstract, but the fact is they’ve been a terrible steward of their App Store. If you search for an app to do something small but useful, instead you’re presented with an ocean of identical apps that all have $10 a week subscription fees. The golden age of “hey I’ll just go on the App Store and buy something handy for $3” has long past, and a lot of those few-dollar apps have…

I have an Android phone, and almost everything I use on it is installed through F-Droid or directly from the author's Git repository. Every time I do something useful on my phone, and iPhone users ask how to do it, there's nothing equivalent available for a their phone.

The worst part is the maintenance required just to keep the same unchanged software available to new phones. You have to pay annually to keep your account open, and regularly recompile the application for new OS versions, even when the OS is backward compatible. This not only means someone's open-source weekend project isn't going to be worth publishing for free, but it won't even be worth publishing for a one-time charge. For the simplest utilities, everything is shifting to recurring charges. Often that entails someone else compiling an open-source application to iOS, filling the market with sketchy unofficial releases, with predatory billing schemes and unexpected add-ons.

Sometimes Apple straight-up prohibits useful utilities. One of the most useful things a phone can do is act as a portable Wi-Fi signal analyzer, logging signal strength and signal to noise ratios from various locations. That's not even allowed by Apple.

Re: Like a Bouncer at a Bookstore: Texas' App Store Accountability Act

#14

Post by dlcarrier »

Cider9986 wrote: post #5

This law is terrible and I hope it isn't implemented, but it's enabled by the locked down and centralized nature of iOS and the way most people get apps on Android, the Play store. Once you try Android, you can't go back. I used an iPhone all my life, but a few months ago I switched to GrapheneOS and the FOSS software ecosystem is fantastic. On iPhones, if a government doesn't want an app, like those ICE tracking app…

I may be a bit out of the loop, because I still drive a car with a solid metal key and a manual transmission, but why would your car care what OS your phone is running?

Re: Like a Bouncer at a Bookstore: Texas' App Store Accountability Act

#15

Post by drivingmenuts »

bad_haircut72 wrote: post #4

I wish Texans realised that sovereignty over your own computer was in the same camp as the right to bear arms - the power to control your own life and not have someone else control you. Maybe this is a sign they're starting to get it.

A lot of Texans do. We didn't elect those Texans and if the current legislature has their way, we never will. The Legislature and Governor, et all, are too busy trying to implement the Republic of Gilead, the Old South and the State of Elon combined to think about anything else.

Re: Like a Bouncer at a Bookstore: Texas' App Store Accountability Act

#16

Post by Cider9986 »

dlcarrier wrote: post #14
Cider9986 wrote: post #5

This law is terrible and I hope it isn't implemented, but it's enabled by the locked down and centralized nature of iOS and the way most people get apps on Android, the Play store. Once you try Android, you can't go back. I used an iPhone all my life, but a few months ago I switched to GrapheneOS and the FOSS software ecosystem is fantastic. On iPhones, if a government doesn't want an app, like those ICE tracking app…

I may be a bit out of the loop, because I still drive a car with a solid metal key and a manual transmission, but why would your car care what OS your phone is running?

Apps occasionally ban alternative operating systems as security theatre because Google tells them to, to enforce Google's monopoly.

Re: Like a Bouncer at a Bookstore: Texas' App Store Accountability Act

#17

Post by microtonal »

_aavaa_ wrote: post #10
Cider9986 wrote: post #5

This law is terrible and I hope it isn't implemented, but it's enabled by the locked down and centralized nature of iOS and the way most people get apps on Android, the Play store. Once you try Android, you can't go back. I used an iPhone all my life, but a few months ago I switched to GrapheneOS and the FOSS software ecosystem is fantastic. On iPhones, if a government doesn't want an app, like those ICE tracking app…

That’s great for Kia, but if I owned at VW it doesn’t do me much good. Same problem with banking apps.

We own a VW and I use GrapheneOS. The problem is that you have to draw a line in the sand somewhere. There are always reasons not to do the right thing and that's how we end up with systems that we don't control and track our every movement.

GrapheneOS now has ~500,000 users and is becoming a force to be reckoned with. But 5,000,000 would be even better. At some point you become hard to deny.

If VW does not fix this soon, our next car is not going to be a VW. Same if our bank decided to block GrapheneOS (very unlikely though, they are a green bank, and I communicated with them in the past about non-certified Android phones and they seemed very supportive).

Post reply on HN