Live data from Hacker News

Trade, merchants, and the lost cities of the Bronze Age (2019) [pdf]

keremcosar.uvacreate.virginia.edu

11–20 of 84 posts

Re: Trade, merchants, and the lost cities of the Bronze Age (2019) [pdf]

#11
post #4
post #2

It's interesting that commerce/business was this sophisticated in the Bronze Age. I guess it's not that surprising given the famous customer service complaint[0] cuneiform tablet to Ea-nāṣir about receiving the wrong grade of copper ingots and his servant receiving rude service. It's also no wonder that the thing a theory describes exists long before the theory itself. We had language well before we had grammarians,…

Everyone points to Ea-nasir, but that's a meme. Meanwhile, Diocletian outlawed price gouging and standardized prices across a variety of goods: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edict_on_Maximum_Prices From Polanyi, Finley, and Weber to Austin and Malkin, we've come a long way in recognizing the sophistication of ancient economic thought.

We are about ~300 years closer to Diocletian than Diocletian was to Ea-nasir. Too bad he didn't have access to Adam Smith, who could have told him that price fixing wouldn't work and might have pointed to Roman currency debasement as one of the major causes of inflation. Of course greed is always a factor I suppose.

Re: Trade, merchants, and the lost cities of the Bronze Age (2019) [pdf]

#12

This is AI generated slop.

What signs do you see?

Long sequences of short sentences. Not X, but Y.

And Pangram flags it, too.

https://www.pangram.com/history/126831e1-562f-4e65-9874-5250...

Re: Trade, merchants, and the lost cities of the Bronze Age (2019) [pdf]

#14
post #3

“The word “capitalism” would not be coined for another 3,800 years. Adam Smith was 3,700 years from picking up his pen.” This is pretty bad writing lol. Markets are as old as civilization itself, Adam Smith obviously knew this. General commerce != capitalism

I'm looking for the tablet that says "We're an anarcho-syndicalist commune..."

Re: Trade, merchants, and the lost cities of the Bronze Age (2019) [pdf]

#15
post #2

It's interesting that commerce/business was this sophisticated in the Bronze Age. I guess it's not that surprising given the famous customer service complaint[0] cuneiform tablet to Ea-nāṣir about receiving the wrong grade of copper ingots and his servant receiving rude service. It's also no wonder that the thing a theory describes exists long before the theory itself. We had language well before we had grammarians,…

You forget to mention life and biology, earth and geology, universe and cosmology.

Re: Trade, merchants, and the lost cities of the Bronze Age (2019) [pdf]

#16
post #10

I hope people get the right message from this, which is: The way people talk about "Capitalism" is most often silly and counterproductive because most of the time -- the person that hates capitalism and the person that loves capitalism are talking about nearly entirely different things.

Also, should we capitalize the "C" in "Capitalism"? One might think we should, because C is a capital letter. But capital itself is lowercase, and therein lies the paradox.

Re: Trade, merchants, and the lost cities of the Bronze Age (2019) [pdf]

#18
A lot of people underestimate the bronze age and all the limelight goes to later Greeks and Romans because we have better records of them. But the bronze age and its empires were just as impressive in my opinion. Tin is not a very common metal to find and there are only significant deposits in a limited number of places around the globe. The trade routes required to support bronze production were thousands of miles long.

Re: Trade, merchants, and the lost cities of the Bronze Age (2019) [pdf]

#19
post #10

I hope people get the right message from this, which is: The way people talk about "Capitalism" is most often silly and counterproductive because most of the time -- the person that hates capitalism and the person that loves capitalism are talking about nearly entirely different things.

Capitalism was a term coined by Marx, so not really surprising that most using it are anti-capitalist.

Re: Trade, merchants, and the lost cities of the Bronze Age (2019) [pdf]

#20
post #3

“The word “capitalism” would not be coined for another 3,800 years. Adam Smith was 3,700 years from picking up his pen.” This is pretty bad writing lol. Markets are as old as civilization itself, Adam Smith obviously knew this. General commerce != capitalism

I'm looking for the tablet that says "We're an anarcho-syndicalist commune..."

Obviously not exactly that, but egalitarian regims in complex societies was apparently a thing, or at least strong evidences back this scenario.

https://asiatimes.com/2023/06/mystery-of-missing-indus-valle...

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/history/article/indus-val...

Post reply on HN