Live data from Hacker News

The placeholder name for the Windows 8 experience was "modern"

devblogs.microsoft.com

11–20 of 57 posts

Re: The placeholder name for the Windows 8 experience was "modern"

#12
post #7
post #4

"Modern" = something that ruins perfectly good stuff in the never ending pursuit of "progress". UI doesn't need to change every few years. It should have stopped changing almost 30 years ago.

This. I don't see the point of constantly changing UI as an end-user. The old one just work. It works perfectly. Now that you changed it and thing breaks. :|

It's still broken to this day

Re: The placeholder name for the Windows 8 experience was "modern"

#14

When you put "modern" or "new" into the name of a thing, you're basically announcing to the world that it was designed for the short term, and when it is no longer new it will no longer be relevant.

No. Modern like 1950's modern. Unadorned, functional.

1900s: Noveau - plant shapes. 1940s: deco - geometry. Windows XP: gradients, color. Windows Vista: semitransparency.

1950s, Windows 8: 'modern' - strip away unnecessary decoration.

Re: The placeholder name for the Windows 8 experience was "modern"

#15
Hot take: I liked Windows 8. It used less memory than Windows 7, increased battery life, the file manager and task manager were much improved, I could mount ISOs without third party software, among other things. In truth, I didn't even mind the start screen. And I certainly liked Metro as a UI paradigm much more than Aero.

Of course it was still Windows at the end of the day, but 8.1 was my last Windows. The laptop I ran it on is slowly bitrotting in a storage locker somewhere on the other end of the country. I didn't like the look of Windows 10, several aspects of it were hard dealbreakers, so I never swapped to it. Eventually I just changed over to using Linux as my primary OS and haven't really looked back.

Re: The placeholder name for the Windows 8 experience was "modern"

#16
I read somewhere that the visual design of Windows 8 was based on the works of Mondrian, because they wanted a design that didn’t just look like the Swiss School that Apple had adopted.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Stijl

I don’t know if the idea of calling Windows 8 modern stemmed from that, or if they decided to pick Mondrian having already decided to go with modern.

Re: The placeholder name for the Windows 8 experience was "modern"

#18

When you put "modern" or "new" into the name of a thing, you're basically announcing to the world that it was designed for the short term, and when it is no longer new it will no longer be relevant.

Adding "fast" is similarly fun, it's probably true when you came up with it, probably won't be true in the future anymore.

As is ”simple”.

Re: The placeholder name for the Windows 8 experience was "modern"

#19

https://xkcd.com/3089/

I sort of like the term “early Modern” in history. Putting the “early modern” period 250 years ago causes us to reflect on how much life has changed over that time, which is useful because it’s so tempting to imagine what life was like during the Renaissance or Middle Ages. Of course, every period has massive change, so the experiences of people on either end of a period are as different as somebody in the early modern and… actual modern… eras!
Post reply on HN