That’s nothing new.
That’s just the art scene already ridiculed in the movie Interstate 60 with James Marsden and Gary Oldman and from 2002
What happens when you post a real Monet and say it's AI?
11–20 of 78 posts
Re: What happens when you post a real Monet and say it's AI?
#12I think the more interesting thing going on here is the growing anti-AI sentiment. (Which I very much feel in myself too.)
Re: What happens when you post a real Monet and say it's AI?
#13Being able to imitate Monet doesn't make you Monet. AI can't create anything original.
This is a real Monet.
Re: What happens when you post a real Monet and say it's AI?
#14Seems the poster is the one fooled by the AI more than anything, because most likely the bulk of the replies are bots, so you got AI to criticize AI.
[deleted]
Re: What happens when you post a real Monet and say it's AI?
#15Very good. We need more of these experiments in all areas. Hopefully it helps people to at least be more conscious of their bias.
Re: What happens when you post a real Monet and say it's AI?
#16Shows the pretentiousness of the twitterati more than anything else
[deleted]
Re: What happens when you post a real Monet and say it's AI?
#17Cherry picked, contrived, biased; in a word, slop.
Re: What happens when you post a real Monet and say it's AI?
#18This is like asking people to rate this plate of bugs while serving them chicken. Even if tastes great, of course some people who will have a visceral reaction against it.
But they’re confidently asserting a whole bunch of specific made up reasons this is shittier than a real Monet.
It’s like the sommeliers who can’t detect red vs. white wine when blindfolded.
Re: What happens when you post a real Monet and say it's AI?
#19Two interesting replies: It’s not a physical painting made by a well known artist. It’s trying to hard to be a late Monet. How much of our opinions are driven by context, rather than the actual subject? If Monet’s work is not so great without the context, is it still great? Or is context a critical piece of the art itself? Do we need to view a Monet piece within the scope of other Monet pieces, other artists, time pe…
> How much of our opinions are driven by context
I’d say for art, a lot? There’s a ton of art that a halfway decent painter could do now, the art of it was being the one to do it originally. At least that’s how I, as an absolute philistine in that regard, understand it ;)
Re: What happens when you post a real Monet and say it's AI?
#20Seems the poster is the one fooled by the AI more than anything, because most likely the bulk of the replies are bots, so you got AI to criticize AI.
> Seems the poster is the one fooled by the AI
I think this HN commenter is also being fooled by the AI. It's likely that a lot of comments on HN are bots, so here you got an AI to comment about AI criticizing AI.