Live data from Hacker News

Everyone in the world has to take a private vote by pressing red or blue

twitter.com

11–20 of 26 posts

Re: Everyone in the world has to take a private vote by pressing red or blue

#11

I don't get how so many people say pressing red is the right choice. Yes, if everyone presses red then nobody dies, but the same is true if everyone presses blue. But if almost everyone presses red, a lot of people die, and if almost everyone presses blue still nothing happens. It would be funny if nobody dies but this was just a test if you are capable of large scale coordination - and everybody who presses red just…

The simplest answer is: are you willing to bet your life on the fact that 50% of people on earth won't press red? For one reason or another, the reason they press red doesn't matter. For you, pressing red is safe, you risk nothing. Pressing blue is Russian roulette.

Re: Everyone in the world has to take a private vote by pressing red or blue

#12

I don't get how so many people say pressing red is the right choice. Yes, if everyone presses red then nobody dies, but the same is true if everyone presses blue. But if almost everyone presses red, a lot of people die, and if almost everyone presses blue still nothing happens. It would be funny if nobody dies but this was just a test if you are capable of large scale coordination - and everybody who presses red just…

The simplest answer is: are you willing to bet your life on the fact that 50% of people on earth won't press red? For one reason or another, the reason they press red doesn't matter. For you, pressing red is safe, you risk nothing. Pressing blue is Russian roulette.

[deleted]

Re: Everyone in the world has to take a private vote by pressing red or blue

#14

I don't get how so many people say pressing red is the right choice. Yes, if everyone presses red then nobody dies, but the same is true if everyone presses blue. But if almost everyone presses red, a lot of people die, and if almost everyone presses blue still nothing happens. It would be funny if nobody dies but this was just a test if you are capable of large scale coordination - and everybody who presses red just…

The simplest answer is: are you willing to bet your life on the fact that 50% of people on earth won't press red? For one reason or another, the reason they press red doesn't matter. For you, pressing red is safe, you risk nothing. Pressing blue is Russian roulette.

[deleted]

Re: Everyone in the world has to take a private vote by pressing red or blue

#17

Why would I not press red?

Blue is just like red, but without the death. It's red premium. Why wouldn't you press blue?

Why would I risk death? Why would anyone? Everyone just needs to press red

Re: Everyone in the world has to take a private vote by pressing red or blue

#18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Blue is just like red, but without the death. It's red premium. Why wouldn't you press blue?

Why would I risk death? Why would anyone? Everyone just needs to press red

[dead]

Re: Everyone in the world has to take a private vote by pressing red or blue

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Blue is just like red, but without the death. It's red premium. Why wouldn't you press blue?

Why would I risk death? Why would anyone? Everyone just needs to press red

You'd have to factor in what percentage of people don't understand that if everyone picks red they all live. What percentage of people think that amount is more than zero, then what percentage of those people are willing to take the risk to save those people. Then what percentage of people are willing to take the risk to save the people that took the risk. And so on. Then if you care enough to take the risk yourself.
Post reply on HN