Live data from Hacker News

I'm done making desktop applications (2009)

kalzumeus.com

11–20 of 211 posts

Re: I'm done making desktop applications (2009)

#12

> Why I'm Done Making Desktop Applications To save you a click: It's harder to monetize desktop apps than webapps. Lol. LMAO, even.

it's amazing how freeing working an office job is. my personal projects don't have concerns such as monetization.

Re: I'm done making desktop applications (2009)

#16
post #6

I wonder what the numbers say about desktop applications now, and how much the arrival of Electron changed things up here. Nowadays, it seems to be that mobile apps have the "best metrics" for b2c software. I'd be interested to read a contemporary version of this article.

Electron is the worst of both worlds. I have never paid for an Electron app, and never will. Horrid UX.

Re: I'm done making desktop applications (2009)

#17
Almost all of Patrick's points are great if your software development goal is to make a buck. They don't seem to matter if you're writing open source, and I'd argue that desktop apps are still relevant and wonderful in the open source world. I just started a new hobby project, and am doing it as a cross-platform, non-Electron, desktop app because that's what I like to develop.

The onboarding funnel: Only a concern if you're trying to grow your user base and make sales.

Conversion: Only a concern if you're charging money.

Adwords: Only a concern if, in his words, you're trying to "trounce my competitors".

Support: If you're selling your software, you kind of have to support it. Minor concern for free and open source.

Piracy: Commercial software concern only.

Analytics and Per-user behavior: Again, only commercial software seems to feel the need to spy on users and use them as A/B testing guinea pigs.

The only point I can agree with him that makes web development better is the shorter development cycles. But I would argue that this is only a "developer convenience" and doesn't really matter to users (in fact, shorter development cycles can be worse for users as their software changes rapidly like quicksand out from under them.) To me, in my open source projects, my "development cycle" ends when I push to git, and that can be done as often as I want.

Re: I'm done making desktop applications (2009)

#19
post #6

I wonder what the numbers say about desktop applications now, and how much the arrival of Electron changed things up here. Nowadays, it seems to be that mobile apps have the "best metrics" for b2c software. I'd be interested to read a contemporary version of this article.

Electron is the worst of both worlds. I have never paid for an Electron app, and never will. Horrid UX.

> I have never paid for an Electron app

Your employer most likely has.

Post reply on HN