Live data from Hacker News

MacBook Neo isn't innovation: It's Apple correcting a story it pushed for years

windowscentral.com

11–20 of 21 posts

Re: MacBook Neo isn't innovation: It's Apple correcting a story it pushed for years

#11

This article is framed as if Apple planned all this, and I don’t think that’s the case. It me is seems Apple thought the iPad would be the way of the future, not for everyone, but for most. Jobs compared Mac’s to trucks, while most people would be well served by a car (iPad). This was a bold prediction, but not completely unreasonable. A lot of people these days use their phone as their primary computing device, in m…

Maybe it is the case that if phones hadn't kept getting bigger then tablets as a category would be more popular as a computing device?

Realistically though a tablet kind of feels like a small TV these days, which is a screen with some apps on it for media consumption. Most people have a TV already for big media consumption, and then their phone will suffice for small scale media consumption, so tablets are a very niche thing for people that have the money and don't feel like using their phone for whatever reason.

Re: MacBook Neo isn't innovation: It's Apple correcting a story it pushed for years

#12
post #6

I got an iPad Pro a while back. I use iPads mainly to hold music scores, and at the time, the Roland Piano Keyboard just would not hold a laptop securely. Since then, I got a Yamaha Clavinova to replace the Roland and there always was the real piano. While both will hold a laptop securely, laptops are expensive displays. If I change from the iPad Pro, it will be to a mini with a 17 inch monitor, even bigger. Both of…

> getting an image URL are basically impossible except for McGuyver tricks Assuming you're talking about an image in the browser? Long press, drag it to the address bar, that'll load the image alone and you can copy the address from the bar.

My experience is it doesn’t work all of the time because many websites add their shenanigan Javascripts to restrict the selection or extracting images

Re: MacBook Neo isn't innovation: It's Apple correcting a story it pushed for years

#13
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> getting an image URL are basically impossible except for McGuyver tricks Assuming you're talking about an image in the browser? Long press, drag it to the address bar, that'll load the image alone and you can copy the address from the bar.

My experience is it doesn’t work all of the time because many websites add their shenanigan Javascripts to restrict the selection or extracting images

Alas, there's the screenshot.

Re: MacBook Neo isn't innovation: It's Apple correcting a story it pushed for years

#14
In the Win 8 I thought Microsoft was visionary in integrating the tablet with the PC and in particular had a better vision than either Apple or Google. On the other hand I had a lot of weird ideas that turned out to be wrong or irrelevant: like I thought that 2-in-1s and other hybrids were just insane, like a conspiracy to confuse flight attendants, that Synoptics must be lording over the industry using patents to force every device to have a (worse than useless in my mind) trackpad, that the laptop hinge only existed because of the airline industry, or that the trackpads and insanely expensive cases with special-purpose keyboards just existed because there is so much QRM [1] at the consumer electronics show (CES) that you couldn't expect to demo something that depends on a bluetooth keyboard and mouse.

Around that time my hackathon kit was a bottom-of-the-line Android tablet with a $5 plastic clip and a cheap bluetooth keyboard and cheap mouse and with $75 of client hardware I would connect to a $2 hour machine in AWS and have a machine that was so sleek it made macbooks look clunky in comparison and also vastly more powerful than the bulky desktop replacement laptops and the gaudy gaming laptops -- it turned heads.

People thought my kit was fashionable but that's all the agreement I got with my vision. Laptops still have hinges, there is no resistance against crap trackpads [2] and those expensive cases, people are still surprised you can use a keyboard and mouse with your iPad, etc. I believed in Win 8 and told people "just hit that damn windows key on your keyboard" but I think I was the only one.

[1] ham radio jargon for "radio interference"

[2] even mac-ers admit that Apple trackpads are at best tolerable

Re: MacBook Neo isn't innovation: It's Apple correcting a story it pushed for years

#16
post #6

I got an iPad Pro a while back. I use iPads mainly to hold music scores, and at the time, the Roland Piano Keyboard just would not hold a laptop securely. Since then, I got a Yamaha Clavinova to replace the Roland and there always was the real piano. While both will hold a laptop securely, laptops are expensive displays. If I change from the iPad Pro, it will be to a mini with a 17 inch monitor, even bigger. Both of…

Maybe I should try to do more work on the iPad "Pro" (the OLED display is terrific, the Magic keyboard/trackpad aren't bad at all, and it can even work with a 4K external display and USB mouse/keyboard) but it's my go-to device for creative apps (forScore, Korg Gadget, Procreate, ...), comics, and iOS games.

Re: MacBook Neo isn't innovation: It's Apple correcting a story it pushed for years

#17
post #8

Fair point, but I can’t stop wondering whether the crux of the issue wasn’t the OS and the decisions that go back to iPhone or iPod. I can’t recall the details, but they tried to get MacOS to work and then decided to go with the alternative. I can only speculate on both that MacOS must have had a mobile story/dream since Newton and more so after nexstep. So I wonder if what the article is pointing at wasn’t actually…

> I can only speculate on both that MacOS must have had a mobile story/dream since Newton

https://apple.fandom.com/wiki/PenLite

https://apple.fandom.com/wiki/Freestyle

Re: MacBook Neo isn't innovation: It's Apple correcting a story it pushed for years

#18
post #6

I got an iPad Pro a while back. I use iPads mainly to hold music scores, and at the time, the Roland Piano Keyboard just would not hold a laptop securely. Since then, I got a Yamaha Clavinova to replace the Roland and there always was the real piano. While both will hold a laptop securely, laptops are expensive displays. If I change from the iPad Pro, it will be to a mini with a 17 inch monitor, even bigger. Both of…

Maybe I should try to do more work on the iPad "Pro" (the OLED display is terrific, the Magic keyboard/trackpad aren't bad at all, and it can even work with a 4K external display and USB mouse/keyboard) but it's my go-to device for creative apps (forScore, Korg Gadget, Procreate, ...), comics, and iOS games.

For Score is OK except when a half page scroll puts the line I want to read above the screen.

I use arrow keys for now with the keyboard case. Tapping the screen was not to my liking and $$$ gestures are beyond my skill level. I scrunch too much trying to read notes.

Rarely, I just read the pdf's directly for a non-paged experience.

Re: MacBook Neo isn't innovation: It's Apple correcting a story it pushed for years

#19
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe I should try to do more work on the iPad "Pro" (the OLED display is terrific, the Magic keyboard/trackpad aren't bad at all, and it can even work with a 4K external display and USB mouse/keyboard) but it's my go-to device for creative apps (forScore, Korg Gadget, Procreate, ...), comics, and iOS games.

For Score is OK except when a half page scroll puts the line I want to read above the screen. I use arrow keys for now with the keyboard case. Tapping the screen was not to my liking and $$$ gestures are beyond my skill level. I scrunch too much trying to read notes. Rarely, I just read the pdf's directly for a non-paged experience.

Notes seem big enough in 13" portrait mode. No scrolling.

iPad is also a great PDF device.

Re: MacBook Neo isn't innovation: It's Apple correcting a story it pushed for years

#20
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For Score is OK except when a half page scroll puts the line I want to read above the screen. I use arrow keys for now with the keyboard case. Tapping the screen was not to my liking and $$$ gestures are beyond my skill level. I scrunch too much trying to read notes. Rarely, I just read the pdf's directly for a non-paged experience.

Notes seem big enough in 13" portrait mode. No scrolling. iPad is also a great PDF device.

Be thankful for great vision.

I often have to process scans of PD scores. The paper they replace weighs hundreds of pounds.

Post reply on HN