Live data from Hacker News

Automatic registration for US Military draft to begin in December

thehill.com

11–20 of 77 posts

Re: Automatic registration for US Military draft to begin in December

#11

I still don’t understand why, if they are having trouble with recruitment, they simply won’t raise the pay to entice more recruits? We have a seemingly unlimited budget for bombs but god forbid you pay for smart, qualified people willing to actually do the work. It is as simple as that and not anymore complicated

- The US has had record breaking recruitment in the last 1.5 years. - This policy is a readiness, not an activation. It's not related to current recruitment.

Traditionally the US believes arming the people (2nd Amendment) means we're a stronger nation. Having bases globally makes us a stronger nation. Having everybody registered to the draft makes us a stronger nation.

Re: Automatic registration for US Military draft to begin in December

#12
post #6

> But former President Jimmy Carter in 1980 reinstated the Selective Service in the event of a “national emergency,” where the registry could be used to “provide personnel to the Department of War and alternative service for conscientious objectors, if authorized by the President and Congress.” Department of Defense*

I found that strange as well. Who were they quoting, given that the Department of War hasn’t existed since 1947 and as far as I know Jimmy Carter didn’t pretend that it still did.

Re: Automatic registration for US Military draft to begin in December

#13

I still don’t understand why, if they are having trouble with recruitment, they simply won’t raise the pay to entice more recruits? We have a seemingly unlimited budget for bombs but god forbid you pay for smart, qualified people willing to actually do the work. It is as simple as that and not anymore complicated

Joining the military is not just a job. The baggage is considerably different than every other job.

The obvious difference is that you cannot quit.

Re: Automatic registration for US Military draft to begin in December

#14
post #3

Automatic registration means young adults will not have the consciously confront the possibility. This will certainly decrease the number of people establishing the paper trail that they are contentious objectors.

Conscientious objectors represent an exceptionally small proportion of the population as it is.

Re: Automatic registration for US Military draft to begin in December

#15
post #9

I still don’t understand why, if they are having trouble with recruitment, they simply won’t raise the pay to entice more recruits? We have a seemingly unlimited budget for bombs but god forbid you pay for smart, qualified people willing to actually do the work. It is as simple as that and not anymore complicated

What you wrote has nothing to do with the article. The draft is for (a) massively unpopular wars that the public won't consent to (b) existential wars that require huge manpower. It's for cannon fodder; not at all for "smart", "qualified" people.

[deleted]

Re: Automatic registration for US Military draft to begin in December

#16

I still don’t understand why, if they are having trouble with recruitment, they simply won’t raise the pay to entice more recruits? We have a seemingly unlimited budget for bombs but god forbid you pay for smart, qualified people willing to actually do the work. It is as simple as that and not anymore complicated

- The US has had record breaking recruitment in the last 1.5 years. - This policy is a readiness, not an activation. It's not related to current recruitment. Traditionally the US believes arming the people (2nd Amendment) means we're a stronger nation. Having bases globally makes us a stronger nation. Having everybody registered to the draft makes us a stronger nation.

The big problem is that having a demented and kompromised "president" whose handlers launch ill-advised unwinnable wars that give away needless victories to our adversaries makes us a weaker nation.

Re: Automatic registration for US Military draft to begin in December

#17
post #6

> But former President Jimmy Carter in 1980 reinstated the Selective Service in the event of a “national emergency,” where the registry could be used to “provide personnel to the Department of War and alternative service for conscientious objectors, if authorized by the President and Congress.” Department of Defense*

It was historically called "Department of War" then renamed to "Department of Defense" and of course, recently reverted to the original name.

Re: Automatic registration for US Military draft to begin in December

#18
post #9

I still don’t understand why, if they are having trouble with recruitment, they simply won’t raise the pay to entice more recruits? We have a seemingly unlimited budget for bombs but god forbid you pay for smart, qualified people willing to actually do the work. It is as simple as that and not anymore complicated

What you wrote has nothing to do with the article. The draft is for (a) massively unpopular wars that the public won't consent to (b) existential wars that require huge manpower. It's for cannon fodder; not at all for "smart", "qualified" people.

Not to mention, in the event of required increase in personnel, why "pay to entice" when you can "legally compel" without needing to pay more to the plebs?

Re: Automatic registration for US Military draft to begin in December

#19

I'm for this, but what happened to equal rights? What about women?

The way to make women ad men equal with respect to the draft is to repeal the Military Selective Service Act, as supported by many feminists:

https://hasbrouck.org/draft/repeal.html

More on what femninists say about the dratt and draft registration: https://hasbrouck.org/draft/women/feminism.html

Re: Automatic registration for US Military draft to begin in December

#20
post #9

I still don’t understand why, if they are having trouble with recruitment, they simply won’t raise the pay to entice more recruits? We have a seemingly unlimited budget for bombs but god forbid you pay for smart, qualified people willing to actually do the work. It is as simple as that and not anymore complicated

What you wrote has nothing to do with the article. The draft is for (a) massively unpopular wars that the public won't consent to (b) existential wars that require huge manpower. It's for cannon fodder; not at all for "smart", "qualified" people.

1 point by ehasbrouck 1 minute ago | root | parent | next | edit | delete [–]

The Selective service System is required by law to maintain readiness to activate either of two types of draft: a "cannon fodder" draft of males 18-25, or a "Health Care Personnel Delivery System" for men and women up to age 45 in 57 occupations: https://medicaldraft.info

Congress could decide to expand the latter to other non-medical occupations as a broader "special skills" draft.

Post reply on HN