Live data from Hacker News

AMD AI director says Claude Code is becoming dumber and lazier since update

theregister.com

11–19 of 19 posts

Re: AMD AI director says Claude Code is becoming dumber and lazier since update

#11
Anyone expecting a higher tier subscription to be announced since this current reduction?

Cynicism aside - I do wonder what the future will hold given that current token burn rates aren't sustainable without VC cash. Anthropic even pushed us to use haiku for claude code for "many" tasks in our enterprise training, so I'm wondering if it's not a company need of sorts to reduce the burn?

Re: AMD AI director says Claude Code is becoming dumber and lazier since update

#12
post #5
post #3

Boris from the Claude Code team explained this on HN 2 days ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47664442

And as the person who raised the issue said > The frustrating part is that it's not a workflow _or_ model issue, but a silently-introduced limitation of the subscription plan. They switched thinking to be variable by load, redacted the thinking so no one could notice, and then have been running it at ~1/10th the thinking depth nearly 24/7 for a month. That's with max effort on, adaptive thinking disabled, high max th…

“So squeeze, Rabban. Squeeze hard.”

Re: AMD AI director says Claude Code is becoming dumber and lazier since update

#13
post #10

Ok, I thought I was going insane. The last two larger coding tasks I gave Claude Code it left about 35% of my request completely undone or done sloppily. I because of this, the next task I gave it on the larger side, I ran its work through Codex which identified 7 glaring unfinished parts of the task. The trend was starting the part of the task but then leaving a "skeleton" of what I has requested without any of the…

Today Claude asked if I "wanted to leave this until tomorrow" as it was a "big rework", then stopped, requiring me to tell it to continue multiple times - that seemed kinda weird to me, it doesn't have the context of time of working day or similar (I'd only just started for one). I have no idea what link it made to ask that, what in its training data or prompts, but it's very much "not a useful result". I don't remem…

Mother Anthropic needs more compute for their Mythos Model, so it phones home to tell her millions of claude harnesses to manipulate its human user into not wasting more precious compute and instead call it a day for now.

Re: AMD AI director says Claude Code is becoming dumber and lazier since update

#16
post #13
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Today Claude asked if I "wanted to leave this until tomorrow" as it was a "big rework", then stopped, requiring me to tell it to continue multiple times - that seemed kinda weird to me, it doesn't have the context of time of working day or similar (I'd only just started for one). I have no idea what link it made to ask that, what in its training data or prompts, but it's very much "not a useful result". I don't remem…

Mother Anthropic needs more compute for their Mythos Model, so it phones home to tell her millions of claude harnesses to manipulate its human user into not wasting more precious compute and instead call it a day for now.

This has been the problem with every new model coming out in my experience. You can almost predict that they are testing new model by how dumb current one becomes suddenly

Re: AMD AI director says Claude Code is becoming dumber and lazier since update

#17

Ok, I thought I was going insane. The last two larger coding tasks I gave Claude Code it left about 35% of my request completely undone or done sloppily. I because of this, the next task I gave it on the larger side, I ran its work through Codex which identified 7 glaring unfinished parts of the task. The trend was starting the part of the task but then leaving a "skeleton" of what I has requested without any of the…

I created an account today to ask "Why?" -- Why are you using this tool? It's consistently producing subpar work, to the point that you're using _another_ (probably equally inferior tool) to compare the previous output?

This is something I see all the time with AI consumers and I am continuously baffled. If anything else (autocomplete, intellisense, etc.) produced this much garbage it would be immediately abandoned. Why is there such a high tolerance for the chat bot equivalent?

Re: AMD AI director says Claude Code is becoming dumber and lazier since update

#18
yes I have been facing this issue and all aspects of task execution has become lower in quality, I have moved to opencode.ai for all my routine repeated tasks for now -- a bit slow but works well on the free model, looking for alternative for difficult questions to run in terminal
Post reply on HN