Live data from Hacker News

The CMS is dead, long live the CMS

next.jazzsequence.com

11–20 of 106 posts

Re: The CMS is dead, long live the CMS

#12
post #9

I expect the bigger risk to dynamic database-backed CMS platforms right now is that AI assistance makes static site generator tools run against a version controlled repository of content less intimidating for most users... and static sites are cheaper to run (especially in this era of badly coded scrapers flooding the internet) and much less likely to fall vulnerable to security problems. I expect we'll see a further…

Depends on the company level, on my line of business, what companies care about are headless CMS, with AI workflows, and oriented towards MACH.

Ah, and all of them have partnerships with Vercel, and possibly Netlify.

Sitecore, Contentful, Sanity, Storybrook,...

If anything, they killed the need for backend skills, you get a ready made SaaS, program interactions with AI, and if anything requires backend like logic, it is taken care by Vercel or Netlify functions.

Re: The CMS is dead, long live the CMS

#13
post #5

I never really understood the argument, you can design the frontend with AI anyway and then use WordPress as the CMS for clients. Clients want to be able to log in, update CPTs, edit a calendar, post pictures, things like that. Surely the idea isn't to vibe-code an admin panel/cms from scratch for every project?

For client projects I tend to go with KirbyCMS. Easy license, great functionality, very easy to setup and configure for the client side users. And way less bloated. I actually really dig it and nearly exclusively use it for my projects.

But other tools are great as well, like ProcessWire (named above).

Re: The CMS is dead, long live the CMS

#16
post #7

> Joost de Valk, founder of Yoast SEO, wrote about how he migrated his personal blog from WordPress to Astro, the hottest new JavaScript framework in town, and suggested the blasphemous idea that not all sites need a CMS (he’s since migrated again to EmDash, which I talk about later) That's a weird thing to read. (Not criticism for the author or the article) > Migrated his personal blog Is that a thing worth mentioni…

>founder of Yoast SEO,

>wrote about how he migrated his personal blog from WordPress to Astro

>he’s since migrated again to EmDash

Do you need to know anything more about this guy? If that's one of the articles sources, I think you can ignore anything it says.

Re: The CMS is dead, long live the CMS

#17
post #9

I expect the bigger risk to dynamic database-backed CMS platforms right now is that AI assistance makes static site generator tools run against a version controlled repository of content less intimidating for most users... and static sites are cheaper to run (especially in this era of badly coded scrapers flooding the internet) and much less likely to fall vulnerable to security problems. I expect we'll see a further…

[deleted]

Re: The CMS is dead, long live the CMS

#18
post #9

I expect the bigger risk to dynamic database-backed CMS platforms right now is that AI assistance makes static site generator tools run against a version controlled repository of content less intimidating for most users... and static sites are cheaper to run (especially in this era of badly coded scrapers flooding the internet) and much less likely to fall vulnerable to security problems. I expect we'll see a further…

There's Tina CMS for editing files in Git, but honestly editing flat files is probably the least interesting or complicated part of an enterprise CMS, and IMO there's rarely a good reason to interact with files directly versus a database that publishes files.

Re: The CMS is dead, long live the CMS

#19
post #7

> Joost de Valk, founder of Yoast SEO, wrote about how he migrated his personal blog from WordPress to Astro, the hottest new JavaScript framework in town, and suggested the blasphemous idea that not all sites need a CMS (he’s since migrated again to EmDash, which I talk about later) That's a weird thing to read. (Not criticism for the author or the article) > Migrated his personal blog Is that a thing worth mentioni…

>founder of Yoast SEO, >wrote about how he migrated his personal blog from WordPress to Astro >he’s since migrated again to EmDash Do you need to know anything more about this guy? If that's one of the articles sources, I think you can ignore anything it says.

Yoast SEO is a huge paid plugin for Wordpress, so the founder not using Wordpress is at least moderately interesting, in a "cobbler buys shoes at walmart" kind of way.

Re: The CMS is dead, long live the CMS

#20
I have built a product which uses AI to built Astro sites. LLM builds the sites in steps and make sure that they get 100/100 scores in pagespeed insights. These sites are served with a CDN. You can edit the sites with LLM interface, or use markdown editor to edit sites, or edit texts directly on a dashboard. These sites are static. There is no vendor lock in. If you want to migrate and manage yourself, just go to cloudflare or github pages. These sites cost 0 eur to run, and they always score better in all benchmarks compared to sites that are built on top of a separate CMS server.

I know WordPress is going nowehere and if there is some special backend functionality, that is needed. But 95% of web does not need it.

A static site is always cheaper, and the bottleneck has always been that editing code is indimidating. Therefore, AI actually resolves a big problem here, and this is going to alter the future of platforms like WP.

Post reply on HN