Live data from Hacker News

Will the AI data centre boom become a $9T bust?

ft.com

11–20 of 83 posts

Re: Will the AI data centre boom become a $9T bust?

#11
I replaced a $22/hr worker entirely with AI. And it costs me about $0.18/hr instead. The AI does a better job, is more reliable and consistent. The human was constantly behind schedule, made frequent mistakes, and also humans get sick, or call off work for other reasons.

So yes, AI is a bubble, but this bubble has generated value, it’s not at all like 2008.

Re: Will the AI data centre boom become a $9T bust?

#13
post #4

Better hope not. If the AI bubble pops it’s going to make the dotcom bubble look like a tiny divot in the road.

why? its all private money funding AI at the moment, sure some data centre reality companies would go belly up but you will be surprised to find out how much of it is big headlines and very little action. there is a lot of installations and GPUs not yet brought online but marked as sold because of .. well physical world delays.

Let me put it this way, IF AI is a bubble then I'd like it to go bust asap instead of dragging along and going public and then us discovering BS/creative accounting revenue in S1 filings. by then it would be much worse. Right now VCs and PE firms will absorb it all.

The thing with dot-com was that there was actual public market corruption & euphoria. that caused the bust painful for everybody. RN its bigtech & PE how has heavy cash reserver and margins to bun through. I'd much rather have them take it then average 401k.

Re: Will the AI data centre boom become a $9T bust?

#15

I replaced a $22/hr worker entirely with AI. And it costs me about $0.18/hr instead. The AI does a better job, is more reliable and consistent. The human was constantly behind schedule, made frequent mistakes, and also humans get sick, or call off work for other reasons. So yes, AI is a bubble, but this bubble has generated value, it’s not at all like 2008.

The value is negative to that worker, apparently.

Re: Will the AI data centre boom become a $9T bust?

#16

I replaced a $22/hr worker entirely with AI. And it costs me about $0.18/hr instead. The AI does a better job, is more reliable and consistent. The human was constantly behind schedule, made frequent mistakes, and also humans get sick, or call off work for other reasons. So yes, AI is a bubble, but this bubble has generated value, it’s not at all like 2008.

Just curious, what did your human worker do that you were able to entirely automate?

Re: Will the AI data centre boom become a $9T bust?

#19
post #4

Better hope not. If the AI bubble pops it’s going to make the dotcom bubble look like a tiny divot in the road.

How would this be a bad thing?

Like New Caledonia the wealth of our nation has been pumped into a get rich scheme looking for a new world

Re: Will the AI data centre boom become a $9T bust?

#20
post #4

Better hope not. If the AI bubble pops it’s going to make the dotcom bubble look like a tiny divot in the road.

The .COM bubble was more than a divot because .COMs in so many industries employed so many people. There was amazon.com, but also pets.com, lowermybills.com, gateway.com. But if our economy somehow loses access to AI (rationing due to wartime efforts? sabotage by a foreign nation? simply not enough grid power to turn them on at the price people are willing to pay?) I would probably need to hire more coders to get the…

AI is driving trades, materials, real estate, all sorts of downstream stuff.

The rest of the economy is dead. Oracle is dead without OpenAI. Remember that unlike the dotcom, none of these companies are public. So when it pops, you’ll see private credit and PE funds implode, which could bring down banks with unhedged exposure. The headlines talk about JP Morgan (which likely has the risk managed), but regional banks got into that nature in the last couple of years in a big way.

Post reply on HN