Live data from Hacker News

Nobody Reads Your Setup Docs

hanzilla.co

11–20 of 23 posts

Re: Nobody Reads Your Setup Docs

#12
post #4

“ And I realized my setup instructions weren’t documentation. They were a wall between my product and the people who wanted to use it.” Assuming this was written by a human, I think it is time to retire saying “this is not x it is y”. The moment I see that I think the text is AI generated and I lose interest.

It feels ai-written, for sure. The sentence structure and idioms are very typical of ai writing these days.

Agreed; I don't think "Not X, but Y" is a reliable tell on its own, but taken as a whole TFA set off my AI writing spidey-sense big time. The intro takes three paragraphs of fluff (ironically) to say "My product used to have long docs, but after using a product with much shorter docs it made me reconsider my approach."

Re: Nobody Reads Your Setup Docs

#13
post #4

“ And I realized my setup instructions weren’t documentation. They were a wall between my product and the people who wanted to use it.” Assuming this was written by a human, I think it is time to retire saying “this is not x it is y”. The moment I see that I think the text is AI generated and I lose interest.

i've noticed recently i actually do that fairly often. so i'm consciously trying to edit after the fact to remove it for that exact reason.

is annoying.

Re: Nobody Reads Your Setup Docs

#15
>The wizard opens your browser to sign in, scans your machine for installed agents, and writes the config to each one. It supports over 30 agents. The user never sees a config file.

In this day and age, I find it interesting that no one is screaming about security and privacy concerns about this which is so prevalent on any social media platform including this one.

Re: Nobody Reads Your Setup Docs

#16
If a "developer" can't manage to read one paragraph in a readme, maybe the "developer tool" is not for them. As much as I usually hate gatekeeping, basic reading comprehension is a skill I'd happily gatekeep at.

Re: Nobody Reads Your Setup Docs

#18

If a "developer" can't manage to read one paragraph in a readme, maybe the "developer tool" is not for them. As much as I usually hate gatekeeping, basic reading comprehension is a skill I'd happily gatekeep at.

Just have an AI make a video out of it, I guess.

Re: Nobody Reads Your Setup Docs

#19

If a "developer" can't manage to read one paragraph in a readme, maybe the "developer tool" is not for them. As much as I usually hate gatekeeping, basic reading comprehension is a skill I'd happily gatekeep at.

Just have an AI make a video out of it, I guess.

Replace the manpage with a tiktok clone. Every video clip is a different section of the manpage. /s

Re: Nobody Reads Your Setup Docs

#20

If a "developer" can't manage to read one paragraph in a readme, maybe the "developer tool" is not for them. As much as I usually hate gatekeeping, basic reading comprehension is a skill I'd happily gatekeep at.

Gatekeeping is much maligned (and not without reason), but I think that the results of no gatekeeping have proven far worse than the gatekeeping ever was. Sometimes, if someone can't put the effort into something, they should be shut out.
Post reply on HN