Some of this AI brings to mind the old Despair "Incompetence" poster ( https://despair.com/products/incompetence ) When you earnestly believe you can compensate for a lack of skill by doubling your efforts, there's no end to what you can't do. For those too young to remember, once upon a time people went into an office to work. And sometimes HR put up motivational posters. And this spawned humorous demotiviational po…
Despair is always with us. The "Adaptation" poster was prescient: The bad news is robots can do your job now. The good news is we're now hiring robot repair technicians. The worse news is we're working on robot-fixing robots - and we do not anticipate any further good news.
Are AI Agents like von Hammerstein's industrious and stupid?
11–16 of 16 posts
Re: Are AI Agents like von Hammerstein's industrious and stupid?
#12AI is simply not an officer. It's a tool. At best, it's a stupid and lazy officer, mere information routers and supervisors. It sounds smart, but it's autocomplete. If a group of students uses it to get ideas for an essay, the whole class will write the same essay, starring the same "Sarah Chen (no relations to Marcus Chen)". That said, throughout history we've delegated decision making to tools. Bone reading, palm r…
Re: Are AI Agents like von Hammerstein's industrious and stupid?
#13This quote is exactly why giving shell privileges to any LLM is idiotic.
Re: Are AI Agents like von Hammerstein's industrious and stupid?
#14Re: Are AI Agents like von Hammerstein's industrious and stupid?
#15All I know is that when I look through my clients' Jira boards, I see an explosion of bugs, outages, and other problems, starting 2 years ago and ramping up so fast that none of the teams can keep up. If AI were working as well as people claim, I'd expect the opposite - work getting delivered faster than the product managers can spec it. Bugs speeding right through the SDLC process. Jira boards sitting mostly empty.…
Or maybe you are building more features than two years ago, which is reflecting positively on other KPIs. You were building one house (feature) per year. After finishing the house you found a few issues (bugs). You get your plumber, electrician..etc to fix each issue. After two years, you start building 10 houses per year. When you finish, you find twice or x times as many issues (bugs) as before. Does that mean your…
Re: Are AI Agents like von Hammerstein's industrious and stupid?
#16But if "stupid" just means can't adapt and repeats what it's told, that's every script and cron job ever deployed. We used to call that automation. Humans can be stupid too, and we don't fire all of them. We put reviews, audits, and liability around them.
AI agents have none of that. A junior dev who breaks prod gets a postmortem. An agent that modifies 50 files gets a git revert. The problem isn't stupidity. It's that there's no structure around it.