Live data from Hacker News

Colon cancer now leading cause of cancer deaths under 50 in US

theguardian.com

11–20 of 226 posts

Re: Colon cancer now leading cause of cancer deaths under 50 in US

#11
post #9
post #2

There is going to be some big AHA moment tied so couple food practices. Like washing chicken in chlorine or something. I wonder how are the stats in other developed countries. The title says US.

My money is on massive overexposure to high fructose corn syrup in the Western diet. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9170474/

lack of fiber is a biggie too. Foods too highly processed. too many oils.

Re: Colon cancer now leading cause of cancer deaths under 50 in US

#12
post #6

They need to lower the screening to 40. I just had mine at 40, turned out fine luckily. Did it without sedation which my doctor said was rare in US, but common outside of US. I found surprising, wasn't that big of a deal. Pain was probably at a 7/10 during the turns (like 3 times) but ok the rest of the time. A little uncomfortable. Some new sensations, some familiar (feeling like you are crapping your pants). I walk…

Which state did you have it done in if I may ask? I'm in Oregon and haven't been able to find a doc that does it without sedation. I can't be put under sedation for medical reasons, but I definitely need this procedure done sooner than later due to new GI problems.

Re: Colon cancer now leading cause of cancer deaths under 50 in US

#13
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My money is on massive overexposure to high fructose corn syrup in the Western diet. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9170474/

lack of fiber is a biggie too. Foods too highly processed. too many oils.

This is my personal bet. It's just low fiber diets.

Re: Colon cancer now leading cause of cancer deaths under 50 in US

#14

Most people don't eat enough fiber, eat way too much processed junk, and have vitamin and mineral deficiencies. Yet still the overall risk for colon cancer is surprisingly low and takes a long time to develop for everyone but the unluckiest. Earlier screenings are just compensating for poor education. It's not a solution to anything but the question of how to raise insurance costs for young people. Just eat your damn…

After a ton of research, I think the generic suggestion 'Fiber' is not helpful.

Some things to consider:

>There are classifications of fiber, insoluable vs soluable

>Even those classifications are overly generalized, and can/should be broken down into basically individual foods.

>Fiber and the various types have impact on your gut bacteria. If your gut bacteria is bad, you might be fueling growth of bad bacteria.

>You don't actually need fiber

>You don't actually need a colon

>I think gut bacteria management will probably be the next big thing. A combination of more scientific probiotics + fiber/prebiotics.

>I'm guessing the colon cancer thing is probably due to pollutants. Not necessarily air, but could be from food.

Re: Colon cancer now leading cause of cancer deaths under 50 in US

#16
post #2

There is going to be some big AHA moment tied so couple food practices. Like washing chicken in chlorine or something. I wonder how are the stats in other developed countries. The title says US.

My bet is on low-fiber diet and people spending half hour playing with phone instead of getting up from toilet.

Re: Colon cancer now leading cause of cancer deaths under 50 in US

#17

Most people don't eat enough fiber, eat way too much processed junk, and have vitamin and mineral deficiencies. Yet still the overall risk for colon cancer is surprisingly low and takes a long time to develop for everyone but the unluckiest. Earlier screenings are just compensating for poor education. It's not a solution to anything but the question of how to raise insurance costs for young people. Just eat your damn…

> Just eat your damn vegetables!

At least if you can find some not previously doused in poison.

Re: Colon cancer now leading cause of cancer deaths under 50 in US

#18
post #2

There is going to be some big AHA moment tied so couple food practices. Like washing chicken in chlorine or something. I wonder how are the stats in other developed countries. The title says US.

The trend has been down, even for this cancer. Such that I agree there were probably some big AHA moments. But I assert they almost certainly happened 50 years ago.

My expectation is that it is less that there has been a growing trend of this cancer getting worse, and far more that we have gotten better at many other cancers. That is, overall, this is good news on progress. Not a scare headline.

Re: Colon cancer now leading cause of cancer deaths under 50 in US

#19
post #6

They need to lower the screening to 40. I just had mine at 40, turned out fine luckily. Did it without sedation which my doctor said was rare in US, but common outside of US. I found surprising, wasn't that big of a deal. Pain was probably at a 7/10 during the turns (like 3 times) but ok the rest of the time. A little uncomfortable. Some new sensations, some familiar (feeling like you are crapping your pants). I walk…

Which state did you have it done in if I may ask? I'm in Oregon and haven't been able to find a doc that does it without sedation. I can't be put under sedation for medical reasons, but I definitely need this procedure done sooner than later due to new GI problems.

North Carolina. And I wasn't actually aware that some doctors wouldn't do until after I had it done (reading about it online). I just called before my appointment to say I didn't need sedation. They said ok and wrote it down. They weren't really pushy during the appointment other than asking me why I didn't want sedation.

I thought it was going to be awkward but wasn't at all. We just chatted. It was him and an assistant. I was able to watch the TV of my colon while he was doing it.

Re: Colon cancer now leading cause of cancer deaths under 50 in US

#20
post #2

There is going to be some big AHA moment tied so couple food practices. Like washing chicken in chlorine or something. I wonder how are the stats in other developed countries. The title says US.

> An estimated 95% of American adults and children fail to meet daily fiber recommendations, with intake often falling below 10 grams per 1,000 calories consumed

It's tempting to focus on some magic bad ingredient/practice to explain our bad health (like seed oils), but we don't exercise, we eat directly against dietary guidelines, and we eat foods that we know are bad for us.

Now add on to that the social media grifters and industry advocates who tell you that eating poorly is good for you.

I don't blame individuals just trying to live their life though. This is how we've let our whole food environment set up shop.

Post reply on HN