Live data from Hacker News

A solver for Semantle

victoriaritvo.com

11–14 of 14 posts

Re: A solver for Semantle

#11
post #7

Semantle is weird. Words you would expect to be close are not. For example: castle is far from moat and stone. Why?

I think the way the similarity is done is based on word co-occurrence and the dataset used is news articles. So you can imagine that not a lot of news articles mention castle in that context.

I guess I get really frustrated when the rules say you are scored on "how close you are to the secret word, based on your word's meaning" with very little explanation what that means.

Then you have cases that drive me crazy, like the guess "food" is very far from the secret word "cupcake", and "toy" is actually very close to "cupcake". What?

Like, come on. This is not playable or fun.

For reference, these are the words close to "cupcake",

https://proximity.clevergoat.com/nearest/Y3VwY2FrZQ%3D%3D

Re: A solver for Semantle

#12
There was a solver years ago that used a similar technique, where you get similarity scores from three fixed words ("giant enemy crab") and it finds the target word instantly:

https://github.com/manimino/semantle-crab

The solver website seems down, but the archived version still works:

https://web.archive.org/web/20220421184123/https://crab.mani...

Re: A solver for Semantle

#13
I like this article a lot, but if I can put forward one mild criticism, it seems to depend entirely on having exactly the same measure of semantic distance for word pairs as the original generator. In that case, as the post shows, you only need several guesses to eliminate all possibilities other than the correct one, just like you only need a few GPS satellite locks to pin down your location.

It would be interesting to see a solver that works more like a human player, where it requires the "warmer" "colder" information from different guesses to hone in, rather than being able to simply look up which words have the exact semantic distance (+/- some fudge factor) from the guess.

Post reply on HN