Live data from Hacker News

Parallella: A Supercomputer For Everyone is Dying

kickstarter.com

11–20 of 67 posts

Re: Parallella: A Supercomputer For Everyone is Dying

#11
post #2

Dying? At $612K of $750K raised with 31 hours to go? Is there something I don't understand there? EDIT: Realizing that mods might change the title at any time, it is right now "Parallella: A Supercomputer For Everyone is Dying"

Nearly $618k as of 16 minutes after your post...

EDIT: $624,602 44 minutes after your post.... I'm getting more optimistic.

Re: Parallella: A Supercomputer For Everyone is Dying

#12
post #2

Dying? At $612K of $750K raised with 31 hours to go? Is there something I don't understand there? EDIT: Realizing that mods might change the title at any time, it is right now "Parallella: A Supercomputer For Everyone is Dying"

They only have 31 hours left to raise the rest of the money. Considering they fact that they took several weeks to reach this point it seems unlikely that they will hit the goal, and therefore they will not secure any of the pledged funds.

It slowed down for a long time, but it's sped up again the last few days, and in less than the last 20 minutes they've gotten another $6k. It's going to be close either way it seems.

Re: Parallella: A Supercomputer For Everyone is Dying

#13

I'm impressed that they made it as far as they have. $612k puts them in the top tier of all Kickstarter projects, but unfortunately they look to have set their goal too high. Maybe they can pull a Clang and raise a ton of money in the last 24 hours, but I'd be surprised to see that happen. Here's hoping I'm wrong.

I think they will succeed.

They're selling something that's really cool and a lot of people want to see succeed, but for which there aren't any software applications to take advantage of yet.

That's the type of project where a lot of people could donate at the end so that it succeeds. Opposed to say, a game, where there's a ton at the beginning and than it slowly trails off.

Re: Parallella: A Supercomputer For Everyone is Dying

#14
post #8

Hasn't Amazon already done this with EC2? (Edit: Written in response to the title.)

Huh? How does this have anything to do with EC2?

Parallella is an dual core ARM board with an FPGA and a 16 core Epiphany CPU (full general purpose CPU cores with 32k static RAM built into each core - all the cores can access the memory of all other cores as well as system RAM). 1GB RAM total. Expected size around a credit card or so.

The main purpose is the Epiphany CPU, which they also have a 64 core version of. Their problem is that their current CPU's are produced using a process that gives them very low yields and very high per-CPU cost. The main goal of the bounty is to enable them to switch to a much higher yield process and bring the per-chip cost of the 16 core version down to a few dollars per chip.

Their long term roadmap is boards with 1000+ cores.

Re: Parallella: A Supercomputer For Everyone is Dying

#15
post #2

Dying? At $612K of $750K raised with 31 hours to go? Is there something I don't understand there? EDIT: Realizing that mods might change the title at any time, it is right now "Parallella: A Supercomputer For Everyone is Dying"

The title suggests they get nothing if they don't raise the $750,000 target, which is true.

Re: Parallella: A Supercomputer For Everyone is Dying

#16

I'm impressed that they made it as far as they have. $612k puts them in the top tier of all Kickstarter projects, but unfortunately they look to have set their goal too high. Maybe they can pull a Clang and raise a ton of money in the last 24 hours, but I'd be surprised to see that happen. Here's hoping I'm wrong.

I think they'll make it easily, sort of like what happened to Dalton Caldwell's App.net ... they got a ton of support in the last 12-24 hours.

Maybe this is cynical, but there seems to be little reason for them to not borrow enough from friends and family to collect from Kickstarter, and pay them back immediately after. Unless the gifts are ridiculously expensive?

Re: Parallella: A Supercomputer For Everyone is Dying

#17
post #9
post #5

For some reason, I thought it relates to the concept of copying the brain of the dead to the computer so that they can live on as disembodied souls in the computer. It just turns out to be a kickstarter project for a powerful computer.

It's not so much that it's a powerful computer, but a computer architecture that can scale up to be a very powerful system. The version they're trying to fund is a cost reduced version including their 16 core chip. They also have a 64 core chip, and plan to scale it much higher. It's differentiated from GPU's in that each core is a simple but fully independent CPU core, with direct access to main system memory AND to…

How is it different from Tilera and Intel's Xeon Phi?

Re: Parallella: A Supercomputer For Everyone is Dying

#18
I think the market is telling these guys: We don't care about computing power. People are getting by with iPads and Chromebooks powered by ARM cores with 1/8 the computing power of an Intel processor. Don't get me wrong if you want to play around with parallel computing you should love this, and support it. Just don't be surprised when it doesn't reach Pebble funding levels.

Re: Parallella: A Supercomputer For Everyone is Dying

#19
Could someone explain how this is different from GPU computing and regular multi-core CPU computing?

I realize there is a difference...but I'm not quite sure I grasp it yet. GPU computing is a lot of parallel math computations with limited shared memory. I'm assuming the Epiphany CPU is more capable than the simple GPU math units?

How's it different from multi-core CPUs? Just the sheer quantity of cores they have packed in there?

Post reply on HN