Live data from Hacker News

Reading and writing can lower dementia risk by almost 40%, study finds

theguardian.com

11–12 of 12 posts

Re: Reading and writing can lower dementia risk by almost 40%, study finds

#11
post #6

Why is the title so misleading? That isn't at all what the study measured. Just read the article 1) looked at a group of 80-year-olds for 8 years 2) checked their economic status throughout life using reading and leisure time (# of library and museum visits as a proxy) 3) Found that higher scores in lifetime enrichment were associated with a 38% lower risk of Alzheimer’s disease and a 36% lower risk of MCI. They did…

Given that dementia can result from various pathological processes, I wonder what it is about dementia that leads you to conclude that these forms of cognitive stimulation cannot possibly reduce one’s risk. I agree that the title is misleading, though, in large part because it assumes causation, whereas association is about all one can say. At least both absolute and relative risk were mentioned in the write up; that’s rare to see.

The original paper is behind a firewall of course, so I cannot access it. Possibly they controlled for other measures of SES? I don’t know.

Re: Reading and writing can lower dementia risk by almost 40%, study finds

#12
And, once again, health/longevity research where the arrow of causality is very unclear.

Does a stimulating mental environment stave off dementia, or is this a matter of the ability/desire to do something a measure of current capability? If you enjoy reading that effectively says it's something reasonably easy for you and thus is a measure of your mind.

Post reply on HN