Live data from Hacker News

Irish man detained by ICE for 5 months

rte.ie

11–20 of 162 posts

Re: Irish man detained by ICE for 5 months

#11
post #3

[flagged]

> The man concedes he came to the U.S. illegally.

Not according to the article?

> "And I did, I complied with everything they said. They asked me if I had a Green Card, I said I didn't, I said I was married to a citizen and that I had a marriage-based petition in place and I was just about to receive my Green Card and that I had a work permit to be here and work."

> He said he had received the work permit about "a month or so earlier", so as far as he knew he was covered.

Re: Irish man detained by ICE for 5 months

#13
post #3

[flagged]

The correct approach to do this is the K-1 visa. Anything else is a loophole or fraud. This guy thought he could lie and defraud his way to a visa without doing it properly.

Another alternative is the CR-1 visa, also a legitimate pathway.

The New York Times attempted to cover this scheme a few months ago but when you look into all the cases they all involve lying to the government or outright fraud, for example one case they highlighted was of someone who entered on a K-1 visa, which requires marriage within 90 days and which you legally agree to do, marrying TWO YEARS after entry and attempting to adjust status. So basically, committing massive immigration fraud and betting the government won't notice.

Re: Irish man detained by ICE for 5 months

#14
post #3

[flagged]

> The man concedes he came to the U.S. illegally. Not according to the article? > "And I did, I complied with everything they said. They asked me if I had a Green Card, I said I didn't, I said I was married to a citizen and that I had a marriage-based petition in place and I was just about to receive my Green Card and that I had a work permit to be here and work." > He said he had received the work permit about "a mo…

You are completely incorrect. An Employment Authorization Document, which he is referring to, does not imply or confer ANY immigration status.

Re: Irish man detained by ICE for 5 months

#17
post #3

[flagged]

Nowhere in the article does he "concede he came to the U.S. illegally."

Yes it does. He mentions he was able to work because of an Employment Authorization Document associated with his pending I-485 Adjustment of Status, but has been in the US for 20 years.

There is no US visa that allows living there for 20 years without work authorization. He entered illegally (or overstayed illegally) then tried to adjust status based on marriage, which is fraud.

Re: Irish man detained by ICE for 5 months

#18
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The man concedes he came to the U.S. illegally. Not according to the article? > "And I did, I complied with everything they said. They asked me if I had a Green Card, I said I didn't, I said I was married to a citizen and that I had a marriage-based petition in place and I was just about to receive my Green Card and that I had a work permit to be here and work." > He said he had received the work permit about "a mo…

You are completely incorrect. An Employment Authorization Document, which he is referring to, does not imply or confer ANY immigration status.

https://universityfinance.richmond.edu/payroll/international...

An EAD gives a person legal status to work in the United States but has fewer privileges than a green card.

Re: Irish man detained by ICE for 5 months

#20
post #3

[flagged]

Where did it say he arrived illegally? Sounds like he’s awaiting Adjustment of Status based on family ties from getting married but doesn’t say what his status was before

I agree that it doesn't say that in the article, but on the other hand, he admits having been here for 20 years. That definitely implies that he is here illegally and knew it. He likely would get denied a green card as a result of that choice.

As much as I loathe everything about how ICE is conducting their activities these days, this case does not seem like a good candidate for sympathy, it does not look like injustice.

Post reply on HN