Live data from Hacker News

US Immigration on the Easiest Setting

pluralistic.net

11–20 of 159 posts

Re: US Immigration on the Easiest Setting

#11
post #5

Summary: legal immigration is very difficult to impossible. The solution, IMO, isn't "just enter illegally". When you're not a citizen then, quite frankly, the fact that you want to immigrate doesn't matter. It's the country that says whether you should get in or not.

What a novel, insightful conclusion. Thanks for sharing.

Re: US Immigration on the Easiest Setting

#12
post #9
post #4

[flagged]

Immigrants account for ~98% of the American population.

100% if you go back a little further. Large hominids aren’t native to this continent.

BTW have you ever thought about what incredible bad asses people had to be to cross the Bering strait during the ice age with Stone Age tech? We could definitely settle space if we had the will. It’d probably be more comfortable, safer, and easier, even in the early days, than that.

Re: US Immigration on the Easiest Setting

#13
post #2

Question is - why would anyone with cash immigrate to US? Doing business there does not require citizenship. What is it more than doing business that attracts people if one has a citizenship of just about any first world country? I mean, America is about making money, but those people already have money, what else? Citizenship for kids? Just give birth in US. Question again, is why. Top concern for the rich is taxes.…

Buy borrow die.

It's possible it exists in other countries, I don't know that.

Re: US Immigration on the Easiest Setting

#14
post #5

Summary: legal immigration is very difficult to impossible. The solution, IMO, isn't "just enter illegally". When you're not a citizen then, quite frankly, the fact that you want to immigrate doesn't matter. It's the country that says whether you should get in or not.

What a novel, insightful conclusion. Thanks for sharing.

Funny, how the anti ICE crowd wants people to immigrate illegally. What about voting somebody to the office and changing the laws instead?

Re: US Immigration on the Easiest Setting

#15
post #5

Summary: legal immigration is very difficult to impossible. The solution, IMO, isn't "just enter illegally". When you're not a citizen then, quite frankly, the fact that you want to immigrate doesn't matter. It's the country that says whether you should get in or not.

It's the laws of physics that decide whether you actually get in or not.

It's the law of the land that determines how well are you doing once inside.

Re: US Immigration on the Easiest Setting

#16
post #12
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Immigrants account for ~98% of the American population.

100% if you go back a little further. Large hominids aren’t native to this continent. BTW have you ever thought about what incredible bad asses people had to be to cross the Bering strait during the ice age with Stone Age tech? We could definitely settle space if we had the will. It’d probably be more comfortable, safer, and easier, even in the early days, than that.

[flagged]

Re: US Immigration on the Easiest Setting

#17
post #3

I’ve also gone through the US immigration system - got a green card, then naturalized. I did everything myself. And then I did everything for a friend who asked for my help. It’s not hard. It’s just time consuming and the wait times are very long. But it’s really not difficult to fill out the forms and I never used a lawyer.

What about the N-600 form which the article highlights as an impossible barrier for many immigrants to attain their certificate of citizenship. That isn't hard?

Re: US Immigration on the Easiest Setting

#18
post #3

I’ve also gone through the US immigration system - got a green card, then naturalized. I did everything myself. And then I did everything for a friend who asked for my help. It’s not hard. It’s just time consuming and the wait times are very long. But it’s really not difficult to fill out the forms and I never used a lawyer.

Would it have remained as easy if you were scooped up off the street one day by masked men, and deported to a country you've never been to?

Your greencard or documentation may be of no consequence to these masked men, it's up to their mercy or their face scanning app to determine the status you actually have. They may accept your documents at face value OR just deport you no questions asked.

Re: US Immigration on the Easiest Setting

#19
post #2

Question is - why would anyone with cash immigrate to US? Doing business there does not require citizenship. What is it more than doing business that attracts people if one has a citizenship of just about any first world country? I mean, America is about making money, but those people already have money, what else? Citizenship for kids? Just give birth in US. Question again, is why. Top concern for the rich is taxes.…

Higher salary jobs and some very attractive nature. I have chosen _not_ to move there despite those.

Re: US Immigration on the Easiest Setting

#20
post #5

Summary: legal immigration is very difficult to impossible. The solution, IMO, isn't "just enter illegally". When you're not a citizen then, quite frankly, the fact that you want to immigrate doesn't matter. It's the country that says whether you should get in or not.

The Europeans didn't refrain from creating colonies in the Americas after learning it was already inhabited.
Post reply on HN