Live data from Hacker News

Launching the Rural Guaranteed Minimum Income Initiative

blog.codinghorror.com

11–20 of 77 posts

Re: Launching the Rural Guaranteed Minimum Income Initiative

#11

Why rural Americans? The same amount of cash will go a lot further and likely be more effective in rural areas of other countries. The source of Atwood's wealth (Stack Overflow etc) is global, not American.

Why not rural Americans? When helping someone in my community, I don't first stop and analyze whether my time/money could be better allocated to maximize some sort of utilitarian loss function, I help them because they're there, need my help, and I'm able to help.

[flagged]

Re: Launching the Rural Guaranteed Minimum Income Initiative

#13

Why rural Americans? The same amount of cash will go a lot further and likely be more effective in rural areas of other countries. The source of Atwood's wealth (Stack Overflow etc) is global, not American.

He writes:

> because that’s exactly where my parents and I are from.

Re: Launching the Rural Guaranteed Minimum Income Initiative

#14

Why rural Americans? The same amount of cash will go a lot further and likely be more effective in rural areas of other countries. The source of Atwood's wealth (Stack Overflow etc) is global, not American.

Deindustrialization has hollowed out most American cities outside of major cities, and the corresponding anti globalism tantrum contributed to the current political situation. Because of the apportionment of House and Senate seats, these people hold most Americans hostage with their disproportionate voting power, and paying a ransom seems better than the alternative we are living through.

[flagged]

Re: Launching the Rural Guaranteed Minimum Income Initiative

#15
post #13

Why rural Americans? The same amount of cash will go a lot further and likely be more effective in rural areas of other countries. The source of Atwood's wealth (Stack Overflow etc) is global, not American.

He writes: > because that’s exactly where my parents and I are from.

Not to mention one of his choices is a white-minority county in rural Mississippi. The idea that Jeff Atwood of all people is a raging racist is insanely laughable to anyone that has followed his work over the last 15+ years.

Re: Launching the Rural Guaranteed Minimum Income Initiative

#16

Why rural Americans? The same amount of cash will go a lot further and likely be more effective in rural areas of other countries. The source of Atwood's wealth (Stack Overflow etc) is global, not American.

Why not rural Americans? When helping someone in my community, I don't first stop and analyze whether my time/money could be better allocated to maximize some sort of utilitarian loss function, I help them because they're there, need my help, and I'm able to help.

It gives me serious "steal from the poor and give to the rich" vibes. Rural Americans are richer than the majority of humans, and Stack Overflow was a fairly global website.

Rural America also has a government that is fully capable of taking proper care of it's underprivileged; most governments across the world are not.

Re: Launching the Rural Guaranteed Minimum Income Initiative

#17

Why rural Americans? The same amount of cash will go a lot further and likely be more effective in rural areas of other countries. The source of Atwood's wealth (Stack Overflow etc) is global, not American.

Deindustrialization has hollowed out most American cities outside of major cities, and the corresponding anti globalism tantrum contributed to the current political situation. Because of the apportionment of House and Senate seats, these people hold most Americans hostage with their disproportionate voting power, and paying a ransom seems better than the alternative we are living through.

Nope. Globalism has made America richer than pretty much any nation in the existence of human history.

The election of leaders who prioritize the distribution of wealth from the poorest to the richest rather than vice versa has hollowed out rural America.

And rural America disproportionately votes for such leaders.

Re: Launching the Rural Guaranteed Minimum Income Initiative

#18
"Those 10 words had a profound effect on the world. "

And are a paraphrase of even older words:

"From everyone who has been given much, much will be demanded; and from the one who has been entrusted with much, much more will be asked." ~30AD

And probably even older than that.

Re: Launching the Rural Guaranteed Minimum Income Initiative

#19
This is better than nothing, but the big advantage of the UBI is that there is no bureaucracy deciding who gets it and doesn't get it. If there are any conditions on the income, then there's a constant danger that the program will become another tool of control.

Re: Launching the Rural Guaranteed Minimum Income Initiative

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why not rural Americans? When helping someone in my community, I don't first stop and analyze whether my time/money could be better allocated to maximize some sort of utilitarian loss function, I help them because they're there, need my help, and I'm able to help.

[flagged]

What office is Jeff Atwood running for? I can't seem to find that information in TFA.
Post reply on HN