Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

'Melania' promises to take us behind the scenes. There's nothing to see

washingtonpost.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–18 of 18 posts

Re: 'Melania' promises to take us behind the scenes. There's nothing to see

#11

Post by muwtyhg »

delaminator wrote: post #10
Bowes-Lyon wrote: post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ermmmm… How exactly is Rotten Tomatoes gonna verify audiences in e.g. France or Germany or Australia??? The so called „verification“ counts only US users who purchased tickets through the US Fandango app and nobody else, no?

I don't think Melania the documentary is going to be that popular in France, Germany or Australia, do you?

Goalposts successfully moved. Good work.

You can't claim it's 99% audience approved, then say "[only the American] audience [who purchased tickets via Fandango]". If you include the full audience, it has a 28% approval with 5000+ ratings, like the replier indicated.

Re: 'Melania' promises to take us behind the scenes. There's nothing to see

#12

Post by delaminator »

muwtyhg wrote: post #11
delaminator wrote: post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think Melania the documentary is going to be that popular in France, Germany or Australia, do you?

Goalposts successfully moved. Good work. You can't claim it's 99% audience approved, then say "[only the American] audience [who purchased tickets via Fandango]". If you include the full audience, it has a 28% approval with 5000+ ratings, like the replier indicated.

I'm not making any claims, I am reporting what Rotten Tomatoes says

Re: 'Melania' promises to take us behind the scenes. There's nothing to see

#13

Post by muwtyhg »

delaminator wrote: post #12
muwtyhg wrote: post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Goalposts successfully moved. Good work. You can't claim it's 99% audience approved, then say "[only the American] audience [who purchased tickets via Fandango]". If you include the full audience, it has a 28% approval with 5000+ ratings, like the replier indicated.

I'm not making any claims, I am reporting what Rotten Tomatoes says

Your claim is "I would have though[t] verified audience was the more reliable indicator."

That claim is incorrect because it takes in to account only one very small segment of the people who saw the movie (only US, Fandango-based, in-theater viewings are counted). That is not indicative of the wider audience feedback.

You also point out the discrepancy between professional reviewers and audience score ("The audience says: 99% Popcornmeter - 500+ Verified Ratings -The critics say: 10% Tomatometer - 20 Reviews - be careful who you listen to") as a reason for Rotten Tomatoes being untrustworthy, but the Tomatometer and the Popcorn Meter (all audience, not just verified) are close together (10% vs 28%).

Just curious, do you believe this movie to be good? Have you seen it? Or is this just a kneejerk reaction to defend an awful movie where more than 50% of the budget went directly the person the documentary is about?

Re: 'Melania' promises to take us behind the scenes. There's nothing to see

#14

Post by delaminator »

muwtyhg wrote: post #13
delaminator wrote: post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not making any claims, I am reporting what Rotten Tomatoes says

Your claim is "I would have though[t] verified audience was the more reliable indicator." That claim is incorrect because it takes in to account only one very small segment of the people who saw the movie (only US, Fandango-based, in-theater viewings are counted). That is not indicative of the wider audience feedback. You also point out the discrepancy between professional reviewers and audience score ("The audience…

I haven't seen it, nor have any desire to.

but as much as you despise the people who do because you think you are superior in some way

> Melania film earns $7m in US, strongest documentary debut in over a decade

Re: 'Melania' promises to take us behind the scenes. There's nothing to see

#15

Post by muwtyhg »

delaminator wrote: post #14
muwtyhg wrote: post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Your claim is "I would have though[t] verified audience was the more reliable indicator." That claim is incorrect because it takes in to account only one very small segment of the people who saw the movie (only US, Fandango-based, in-theater viewings are counted). That is not indicative of the wider audience feedback. You also point out the discrepancy between professional reviewers and audience score ("The audience…

I haven't seen it, nor have any desire to. but as much as you despise the people who do because you think you are superior in some way > Melania film earns $7m in US, strongest documentary debut in over a decade

You may not have seen it, but are you familiar with the financials of it?

I don't care about the quality of the movie or feeling superior to the viewers who enjoy it. I hate the openly corrupt bribery via the pay she received for this documentary. She received 28 MILLION dollars out of the 40 MILLION dollars paid for the rights to produce this movie. Amazon is effectively purchasing favors from the Trump admin via this movie. That is unacceptable.

Re: 'Melania' promises to take us behind the scenes. There's nothing to see

#16

Post by delaminator »

muwtyhg wrote: post #15
delaminator wrote: post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I haven't seen it, nor have any desire to. but as much as you despise the people who do because you think you are superior in some way > Melania film earns $7m in US, strongest documentary debut in over a decade

You may not have seen it, but are you familiar with the financials of it? I don't care about the quality of the movie or feeling superior to the viewers who enjoy it. I hate the openly corrupt bribery via the pay she received for this documentary. She received 28 MILLION dollars out of the 40 MILLION dollars paid for the rights to produce this movie. Amazon is effectively purchasing favors from the Trump admin via th…

You'll be just as mad when you read about this one then

https://starsandmoney.com/news/michelle-obama-netflix-deal-e...

Re: 'Melania' promises to take us behind the scenes. There's nothing to see

#17

Post by Bowes-Lyon »

delaminator wrote: post #16
muwtyhg wrote: post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You may not have seen it, but are you familiar with the financials of it? I don't care about the quality of the movie or feeling superior to the viewers who enjoy it. I hate the openly corrupt bribery via the pay she received for this documentary. She received 28 MILLION dollars out of the 40 MILLION dollars paid for the rights to produce this movie. Amazon is effectively purchasing favors from the Trump admin via th…

You'll be just as mad when you read about this one then https://starsandmoney.com/news/michelle-obama-netflix-deal-e...

How those two do even compare???

Michele Obama is making a career after she left the White House (after!).

"Melania", on the other hand, constitutes a direct bribe to a sitting (!) president.

Re: 'Melania' promises to take us behind the scenes. There's nothing to see

#18

Post by delaminator »

Bowes-Lyon wrote: post #17
delaminator wrote: post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You'll be just as mad when you read about this one then https://starsandmoney.com/news/michelle-obama-netflix-deal-e...

How those two do even compare??? Michele Obama is making a career after she left the White House (after!). "Melania", on the other hand, constitutes a direct bribe to a sitting (!) president.

Ah yes, the Obamas have no contacts in the political machine and Michelle's extensive media experience is worth a $100m budget.
Post reply on HN