Live data from Hacker News

Two ways to crack a walnut, per Grothendieck (2025)

shreevatsa.net

11–20 of 20 posts

Re: Two ways to crack a walnut, per Grothendieck (2025)

#14
post #12

I get the point of the story but does the soaking method for opening walnuts actually work? Seems to me that you'd likely end up with a rotten nut.

Though I was confident this was just a metaphor, I did try cracking a walnut using this method. I submerged three walnuts in a jar with some tap water, and let them sit for three years before trying to open them.

It was a let-down: they were easier to open, but certainly not by hand, I still had to use a nutcracker. They smelled bad, too. I did not try eating them.

Re: Two ways to crack a walnut, per Grothendieck (2025)

#16

The Grothendieck method can be applied to implementing a new feature in a software system. You just refactor the existing code until the implementation of the new feature becomes trivial.

When reading code you don't really understand, that approach looks a lot like magic. I have a few code bases I try to follow, one is a large Java application, and some of the features added seemingly come out of nowhere. The commit message will just say "Add support for XYZ" and then a few lines added to seemingly random files to setup of condition and then the feature manifests itself.

Re: Two ways to crack a walnut, per Grothendieck (2025)

#17
post #12

I get the point of the story but does the soaking method for opening walnuts actually work? Seems to me that you'd likely end up with a rotten nut.

It is a mixed metaphor, he refers to the problem as a "nut" but says after soaking the nut should open "like a ripe avocado"

Re: Two ways to crack a walnut, per Grothendieck (2025)

#19
post #12

I get the point of the story but does the soaking method for opening walnuts actually work? Seems to me that you'd likely end up with a rotten nut.

I saw someone on You-Tube that soaked them overnight and then used Grandpa's Goody Getter nutcracker to open them. The shells shattered less, he got much bigger pieces, and it wasn't as messy. I have tried both with and without soaking them overnight and I agree that soaking overnight is better than not soaking. You still need a very good nutcracker. https://www.grandpasgoodygetter.com/products/black-walnut-nu...

Re: Two ways to crack a walnut, per Grothendieck (2025)

#20
post #12

I get the point of the story but does the soaking method for opening walnuts actually work? Seems to me that you'd likely end up with a rotten nut.

I saw someone on You-Tube that soaked them overnight and then used Grandpa's Goody Getter nutcracker to open them. The shells shattered less, he got much bigger pieces, and it wasn't as messy. I have tried both with and without soaking them overnight and I agree that soaking overnight is better than not soaking. You still need a very good nutcracker. https://www.grandpasgoodygetter.com/products/black-walnut-nu...

https://youtu.be/iT9kh5Ug1Po?si=9VpvGY1HPYNUE4lR
Post reply on HN