Live data from Hacker News

Why your early 2000s photos are probably lost forever

bbc.com

11–20 of 74 posts

Re: Why your early 2000s photos are probably lost forever

#11

In 2006 I successfully copied all pictures off my Motorola Razr via Bluetooth to my PC in one go. Try doing that with your new iPhone Air. Who's losing old photos again?

It's actually quite simple to copy photos from an iPhone, even my mother-in-law does it regularly to save them, and prints some out as gifts.

Much easier (and faster) than the BT stuff from the Razr era.

Re: Why your early 2000s photos are probably lost forever

#12

In 2006 I successfully copied all pictures off my Motorola Razr via Bluetooth to my PC in one go. Try doing that with your new iPhone Air. Who's losing old photos again?

I regularly export photos from Apple Photos on my Macbook. You just cmd-a cmd-c cmd-v. Sure its clunky but it works.

File -> Export also works, but, like that, only partially. Exporting tagged faces isn’t possible, AFAIK.

Re: Why your early 2000s photos are probably lost forever

#13
On the whole, I consider myself lucky to have lost data due to a badly configured 40GB HDD early in my digital life. I was so aggrieved that it inoculated me against data preservation complacency, and in the subsequent 25 years I haven’t lost a single byte.

As they say, every safety regulation is written in blood.

Re: Why your early 2000s photos are probably lost forever

#14
post #4

In 2006 I successfully copied all pictures off my Motorola Razr via Bluetooth to my PC in one go. Try doing that with your new iPhone Air. Who's losing old photos again?

iPhone AirDrop works really well?

Lot's not get ahead of ourselves. That's the other end of extreme opinion. Airdrop has never worked reliably for me.

Re: Why your early 2000s photos are probably lost forever

#15

In 2006 I successfully copied all pictures off my Motorola Razr via Bluetooth to my PC in one go. Try doing that with your new iPhone Air. Who's losing old photos again?

Very easily.

Even without Apple software, connecting to a Windows PC with a USB cable, iPhone will present itself as a digital camera so you can import photos with the built-in Microsoft photos app or file explorer. You can also use Apple’s Windows software.

On Mac, even without iCloud, you can sync photos “the old way” just like iPod synced content used to do. The photos app will transfer photos over USB or WiFi and you can even have it automatically delete imported photos on your iPhone to free up space, mimicking the workflow of a digital camera.

The Photos app can export to plain files trivially, with a simple drag and drop.

There are also iPhone applications that automatically handle background imports (such as Ente and Google Photos). There are also numerous iPhone transfer apps that can integrate into the share sheet, the possibilities are basically endless.

There’s also AirDrop, or you can move files via the files app to any compatible cloud or local photos app.

Re: Why your early 2000s photos are probably lost forever

#16
post #5

I think things like text messages and related memories are being lost because companies like apple jealously prevent exporting and saving. (camera roll allows export) Lots of relatives lost a phone or access to an account and with it, all photos from friends, text messages to deceased loved ones, and more. all this stuff should be exportable to multiple places for lots of backups on all kinds of media.

Messages, select user, click the user icon to get to the info page, click Photos, Edit, Select, Download -> photos are in the Photos app and you can do what you want with them.

Not the easiest operation, but hardly jealously prevented.

Re: Why your early 2000s photos are probably lost forever

#17
post #16
post #5

I think things like text messages and related memories are being lost because companies like apple jealously prevent exporting and saving. (camera roll allows export) Lots of relatives lost a phone or access to an account and with it, all photos from friends, text messages to deceased loved ones, and more. all this stuff should be exportable to multiple places for lots of backups on all kinds of media.

Messages, select user, click the user icon to get to the info page, click Photos, Edit, Select, Download -> photos are in the Photos app and you can do what you want with them. Not the easiest operation, but hardly jealously prevented.

Self-reply addendum - individual photos can be dealt with with a simple long-press, no need for delving into the info page for the user.

Re: Why your early 2000s photos are probably lost forever

#19
Not only for early 2000's, even now people routinely keep ALL their photos on their phones, without making any copies. Take a photo -> send to someone -> keep them forever -> delete when there's no space left, that's standard lifecycle, at least in my circle.

Re: Why your early 2000s photos are probably lost forever

#20
post #15

In 2006 I successfully copied all pictures off my Motorola Razr via Bluetooth to my PC in one go. Try doing that with your new iPhone Air. Who's losing old photos again?

Very easily. Even without Apple software, connecting to a Windows PC with a USB cable, iPhone will present itself as a digital camera so you can import photos with the built-in Microsoft photos app or file explorer. You can also use Apple’s Windows software. On Mac, even without iCloud, you can sync photos “the old way” just like iPod synced content used to do. The photos app will transfer photos over USB or WiFi and…

I was surprised that exporting from Photos on iOS to an SMB share on a local network Just Works.
Post reply on HN