Live data from Hacker News

UK to "encourage" Apple and Google to put nudity-blocking systems on phones

arstechnica.com

11–19 of 19 posts

Re: UK to "encourage" Apple and Google to put nudity-blocking systems on phones

#11
"Today we're introducing a feature we think you'll love - privacy-preserving FaceTime calls from anywhere. Now you can be running late in your morning routine while still keeping in touch with loved ones and business colleagues. Make it even more fun and express your personal style with ClothesMoji, from business casual to festive seasonal options."

Re: UK to "encourage" Apple and Google to put nudity-blocking systems on phones

#13
An offline AI system in the Camera app that detects when a subject is nude, and educates teenagers of the law and consequences of taking and sending nude photos (through a simple pop-up - "Do you still want to take a nude photo? Yes. No), maybe a good idea. If a user ignores the pop-up and take a nude snap of themselves, for whatever purpose that's their right (and their own problem). There's only so much "nannying" people can do with teens and government can do to us adults.

Re: UK to "encourage" Apple and Google to put nudity-blocking systems on phones

#14
the first line

"prevent phones from displaying nude images except when users verify that they are adults"

first were citizens, then consumers, and now users*

*terms and conditions apply, and will be changed at any time, click I agree to continue

Re: UK to "encourage" Apple and Google to put nudity-blocking systems on phones

#15

An offline AI system in the Camera app that detects when a subject is nude, and educates teenagers of the law and consequences of taking and sending nude photos (through a simple pop-up - "Do you still want to take a nude photo? Yes. No ), maybe a good idea. If a user ignores the pop-up and take a nude snap of themselves, for whatever purpose that's their right (and their own problem). There's only so much "nannying"…

How long until said system then is mandated to detect csam in real time and submit a report wherever you take a photo of what it thinks is csam?

Re: UK to "encourage" Apple and Google to put nudity-blocking systems on phones

#17
post #5

Not everything needs a software based solution. When it comes to nudity I believe that the best way to prevent the spread of nudity is to stop it at the source, right there at the genitals, with physical coverings. This way the nudity is blocked before it has the opportunity to become a victim of mass-dissemination.

I really love this comment.

Re: UK to "encourage" Apple and Google to put nudity-blocking systems on phones

#18

“prevent any nudity being displayed on screen" - full stop? So, constant real-time scanning of whatever is displayed on screen? Are they stupid?

> Are they stupid?

No. They just want to see everything you do. Because, they will need telemetry to assess "usage". And to protect against terrorist. And to protect the children (while storing their pictures in a remote database). And...

Re: UK to "encourage" Apple and Google to put nudity-blocking systems on phones

#19
post #15

An offline AI system in the Camera app that detects when a subject is nude, and educates teenagers of the law and consequences of taking and sending nude photos (through a simple pop-up - "Do you still want to take a nude photo? Yes. No ), maybe a good idea. If a user ignores the pop-up and take a nude snap of themselves, for whatever purpose that's their right (and their own problem). There's only so much "nannying"…

How long until said system then is mandated to detect csam in real time and submit a report wherever you take a photo of what it thinks is csam?

Anything can be politically abused if we, the people, aren't vigilant and allow it to be abused. It doesn't mean we should avoid common sense solutions, just because at some point, some autocrat will abuse it.
Post reply on HN