Live data from Hacker News

High air pollution could diminish exercise benefits by half – study

scienceclock.com

11–20 of 81 posts

Re: High air pollution could diminish exercise benefits by half – study

#11

If only you could see it. In the big cities the air quality has improved, however, I am not sure if it really has, or if we are now just burning hydrocarbons more efficiently so that the particle sizes have become invisible. Put it this way, although cars are allegedly better than they were, fuel consumption hasn't dropped considerably. The cars are more numerous than ever, and, although there are EVs, there are stil…

For urban areas the risk of air pollution is another reason for cities to have congestion pricing to support public transportation.

Re: High air pollution could diminish exercise benefits by half – study

#12

If only you could see it. In the big cities the air quality has improved, however, I am not sure if it really has, or if we are now just burning hydrocarbons more efficiently so that the particle sizes have become invisible. Put it this way, although cars are allegedly better than they were, fuel consumption hasn't dropped considerably. The cars are more numerous than ever, and, although there are EVs, there are stil…

> I am not sure that most people in urban areas even know what good air tastes and smells like.

I run air filters in my apartment throughout winter months, which tend to be the worst in terms of air quality here.

When I go outside in the morning I can really smell the stuff in the air, for a brief moment, until I get used to it. But you definitely notice the difference!

Re: High air pollution could diminish exercise benefits by half – study

#13
post #8
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In the future electric cars and heat pumps will improve the situation.

And how the electricity will be made? Without any CO2 for sure! (or not... yet)

Power plants are usually not placed inside cities. Less gasoline cars inside cities will definitely improve the local situation, not just limited to CO2.

Re: High air pollution could diminish exercise benefits by half – study

#14

If only you could see it. In the big cities the air quality has improved, however, I am not sure if it really has, or if we are now just burning hydrocarbons more efficiently so that the particle sizes have become invisible. Put it this way, although cars are allegedly better than they were, fuel consumption hasn't dropped considerably. The cars are more numerous than ever, and, although there are EVs, there are stil…

Exhaust fumes were easy to optimize.

Lots of particles cars emit are from tires and break pads. I think someone was measuring that but I don’t have sources but most likely I read that somewhere in the comments of HN.

Re: High air pollution could diminish exercise benefits by half – study

#15
post #7

I look at the PM2.5 data for my city every day, and at this point (Nov) in the winter season, the only acceptable time to exercise is between 2PM-4PM after vertical mixing kicked in. Outside that duration, particulates are elevated after morning rush our, after evening rush hour, or during overnight inversion trapping evening rush hour + wood burning smoke until the next morning rush hour. This is one the main reason…

> I am still searching for the best one that works during intense exercis Try a professional mask, like 3M 7500 with 2138 filters.

Thanks, that's one of the masks I use! Unlike the GVS SPM587 it has a quick release thing so you can get to your hydration for water and microplastics :/

Re: High air pollution could diminish exercise benefits by half – study

#16
post #6

It sounds terrible . What will happend in the future?! The research doesn't differentiate between seasons , and every one knows how polluted the air is in the winter when everyone is heating their home and apartament.

In the future electric cars and heat pumps will improve the situation.

You still have break pads and tires particles floating around.

Re: High air pollution could diminish exercise benefits by half – study

#17
post #4

It sounds terrible . What will happend in the future?! The research doesn't differentiate between seasons , and every one knows how polluted the air is in the winter when everyone is heating their home and apartament.

One more reason to look to an electrically heated future. Where I live the air becomes unpleasant in winter as some neighbours heat their homes by burning what i can only assume are old tires and horse carcasses.

I remember as a kid visiting the home of a relative who had an old oven for wood/coal heating, even though the primary heating was now a gas (natural gas not gasoline) heater.

The old oven remained though, and was used as a self-emptying trash can. When it filled up, a fire was lit to empty it. I don't remember what the sorting rules were (I assume "does it burn well and not smell up the apartment too badly when lighting it") and how common plastic packaging was back then, but I'm sure that the emissions coming out from the chimney were not a concern.

Re: High air pollution could diminish exercise benefits by half – study

#18
I want to pull two quotes from the article.

> “Our findings emphasise that exercise remains beneficial even in polluted environments,” lead researcher Professor Po-Wen Ku said in a statement. [...] “We don’t want to discourage people from exercising outdoors,” said Co-author Professor Paola Zaninotto.

The health effects of exercise outdoors are combined from two effects:

- Positive effects due to exercise. These start out strong but level off after a while.

- Negative effects due to pollution. These increase almost linearly with time spent outside.

One might ask, is there an amount of daily exercise at which the negative effects overpower the positive ones? Yes, in a handful of cities around the world, after a few hours of exercise, the pollution makes additional outdoors exercise actually harmful.

But almost everywhere a marginal minute of exercise provides a positive effect on health regardless of time already spent exercising, and there is nowhere in the world where something like an hour of exercise a day is a net negative. Get out there. Pick an active means of commuting (cycling, running, walking, skiing, rollerblading, skateboarding, unicycling) and don't worry so much about pollution unless you live in one of those single-digit cities which I forget where they are, but probably concentrated in Asia.

(I feel bad about typing this out without linking to the source. I'm looking for it in my notes!)

Re: High air pollution could diminish exercise benefits by half – study

#19
Before people freak out about their morning run, I’m very hard pressed to find 25 PM2.5 on this map of the US. (Note these numbers are AQI, you have to zoom into the bad AQI numbers and look at their PM2.5). Albeit it’s a Saturday morning, not rush hour.

China and India look rough though.

https://www.iqair.com/us/air-quality-map

Re: High air pollution could diminish exercise benefits by half – study

#20
post #8
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In the future electric cars and heat pumps will improve the situation.

And how the electricity will be made? Without any CO2 for sure! (or not... yet)

CO2 isn’t particulate matter. But more importantly, larger percentages of our electricity is being made without burning things.
Post reply on HN