Live data from Hacker News

Amazon faces FAA probe after delivery drone snaps internet cable in Texas

cnbc.com

11–20 of 132 posts

Re: Amazon faces FAA probe after delivery drone snaps internet cable in Texas

#11

[flagged]

Solid meh from me. Only thing I really don’t like about it is it’s likely to impact the personal rights to fly drones we enjoy today (which are already being chipped away).

Otherwise, they’re probably not very loud or frequent, don’t really present much of a privacy issue vs. what street view already has, and they maybe make the roads a bit safer. Might take some jobs away from delivery van drivers. Nothing seems worth getting overly concerned for.

Re: Amazon faces FAA probe after delivery drone snaps internet cable in Texas

#13

Maybe we should consider this a chaos monkey test rather than castigating Amazon. If Amazon can accidentally take down internet in a large area with a cheap commercial drone... what can a genuine bad actor do with a few thousand of these. If this is any indicator, half the country is going to be blind and deaf in the first day of a Taiwan war, it's going to be be over before we even get back online.

the ukrainians destroyed hundred million dollar russian bombers with a drone attack in July. drone warfare is very much on-the-radar

Re: Amazon faces FAA probe after delivery drone snaps internet cable in Texas

#15

[flagged]

Solid meh from me. Only thing I really don’t like about it is it’s likely to impact the personal rights to fly drones we enjoy today (which are already being chipped away). Otherwise, they’re probably not very loud or frequent, don’t really present much of a privacy issue vs. what street view already has, and they maybe make the roads a bit safer. Might take some jobs away from delivery van drivers. Nothing seems wor…

Probably half my immediate neighbors get an amazon delivery a day. The truck makes sometimes two or three stops throughout the day and is there for like 15-20 minutes running packages. The thought of that replaced with drone traffic is crazy. It would be like dozens of landings and overflights per hour. It is already bad enough when the realtors fly their drones overhead. I can't imagine the birds and bees aren't getting stressed out if it's managing to piss me off.

Re: Amazon faces FAA probe after delivery drone snaps internet cable in Texas

#16

[flagged]

Consider that drones substitute for cars and trucks driving through neighborhoods.

For the same payload delivered, ground vehicles cause significantly more property damage, environmental damage, and injuries/deaths.

Re: Amazon faces FAA probe after delivery drone snaps internet cable in Texas

#17

It's an ethernet cable, looks like? That's pretty cool that a drone has enough power to break an ethernet cable. It just got tangled in a single cable, looks like it was run across someone's back yard. That's not a bad failure mode, imo - gives them a little exercise in problem solving, figuring out how to prevent ethernet/cable collisions and snags, and maybe results in sensor upgrades, or they figure out good detan…

One internet cable isn't a big deal until it is. Or until it isn't an internet cable. That's what we investigate both near misses and minor issues

Re: Amazon faces FAA probe after delivery drone snaps internet cable in Texas

#18
post #16

[flagged]

Consider that drones substitute for cars and trucks driving through neighborhoods. For the same payload delivered, ground vehicles cause significantly more property damage, environmental damage, and injuries/deaths.

The semi truck isn't driving through my backyard recording video of me. And I doubt the economics of scale make the truck more environmentally damaging than a drone delivering a single item

Re: Amazon faces FAA probe after delivery drone snaps internet cable in Texas

#19
post #16

[flagged]

Consider that drones substitute for cars and trucks driving through neighborhoods. For the same payload delivered, ground vehicles cause significantly more property damage, environmental damage, and injuries/deaths.

That truck carries 500 packages. That drone one or two at best so to replace one truck you're looking at 100's of flights + return flights. And I'm not convinced the risks are lower.

Re: Amazon faces FAA probe after delivery drone snaps internet cable in Texas

#20
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Consider that drones substitute for cars and trucks driving through neighborhoods. For the same payload delivered, ground vehicles cause significantly more property damage, environmental damage, and injuries/deaths.

That truck carries 500 packages. That drone one or two at best so to replace one truck you're looking at 100's of flights + return flights. And I'm not convinced the risks are lower.

Trucks also don't sound like a swarm of angry bees, in fact the all-electric fleet that Amazon uses around here barely sounds like anything at all. Drones would be a huge step backwards for noise pollution.
Post reply on HN