Live data from Hacker News

Holes (1970) [pdf]

rintintin.colorado.edu

11–16 of 16 posts

Re: Holes (1970) [pdf]

#11
post #4

I thought at first that this would be Holes[0], a novel by Louis Sachar. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holes_(novel)

Ie, “Magic Realism for Kids”. It’s an excellent book (as is everything else Louis Sachar wrote).

Re: Holes (1970) [pdf]

#12
post #7
post #6

The essay appears to mix two different meanings of "hole". Holes are a topological property of the slice of cheese. It's not scale invariant, as we're talking about holes on a human visible scale, not microscopic holes. The actual number is not fixed and may depend on the person doing the measuring. I therefore don't see the need for "perforated", much less shape-predicates like "singly-perforated", "doubly-perforate…

I think your definition still leaves the essence of the discussion in the same place: do topological properties "exist"? That's how I tend to blanket-interpret this debate; it's whether one is wiling to define existence to include things that aren't material.

Topological properties exist to the same degree that the number 2 exists, which Argle and Blargle blithely accept.

I still object to how the exchange mixes two different concepts of "hole".

Re: Holes (1970) [pdf]

#13

An old joke that I was thinking about recently: Two local government consultants - tasked with seeing if it'd be financially beneficial to dig a new tunnel so that cars don't have to drive up and down a mountain - dig two small holes on opposite sides of the mountain then stand at either end. The punchline, which I can't remember, is something about the two holes being, according to the two consultants, an MVP of a t…

I don't know that one, but here's a superficially similar joke from somewhere among http://miresperanto.com/humuro.htm :

When the British government invited commercial proposals for the digging of the Channel Tunnel between England and France, one man submitted a bid for only £10,000. “How can you possibly dig under the English Channel for only £10,000?” asked the project manager.

“It’s simple,” replied the low bidder. “My partner takes a spade, goes to France and starts digging. I take another spade and start digging from England. We’ll both keep digging until we meet in the middle.”

“Hm, I see. But what happens if, through a miscalculation, you two do not meet?”

“That’s even better for you!” replied the bidder enthusiastically. “In that case you will have two tunnels!”

Re: Holes (1970) [pdf]

#14

An old joke that I was thinking about recently: Two local government consultants - tasked with seeing if it'd be financially beneficial to dig a new tunnel so that cars don't have to drive up and down a mountain - dig two small holes on opposite sides of the mountain then stand at either end. The punchline, which I can't remember, is something about the two holes being, according to the two consultants, an MVP of a t…

I don't know that one, but here's a superficially similar joke from somewhere among http://miresperanto.com/humuro.htm : When the British government invited commercial proposals for the digging of the Channel Tunnel between England and France, one man submitted a bid for only £10,000. “How can you possibly dig under the English Channel for only £10,000?” asked the project manager. “It’s simple,” replied the low bidde…

A perfect joke, really.

Re: Holes (1970) [pdf]

#15

An old joke that I was thinking about recently: Two local government consultants - tasked with seeing if it'd be financially beneficial to dig a new tunnel so that cars don't have to drive up and down a mountain - dig two small holes on opposite sides of the mountain then stand at either end. The punchline, which I can't remember, is something about the two holes being, according to the two consultants, an MVP of a t…

I don't know that one, but here's a superficially similar joke from somewhere among http://miresperanto.com/humuro.htm : When the British government invited commercial proposals for the digging of the Channel Tunnel between England and France, one man submitted a bid for only £10,000. “How can you possibly dig under the English Channel for only £10,000?” asked the project manager. “It’s simple,” replied the low bidde…

An answer to your puzzle in another post that is locked: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42498953 The "alternate" 5x5 word square that satisfies all the clues without using the words from the first grid is:

    S T R I P
    C H I N A
    R E G A L
    A T O N E
    P A R E R
Breakdown of the solution:

Across

STRIP (Remove the outer layer of, perhaps) — Counterpart to SCALD.

CHINA (Region on a globe) — Counterpart to POLAR.

REGAL (Like some movie theaters; e.g., Regal Cinemas) — Counterpart to ARTSY.

ATONE (Command to a lawbreaker) — Counterpart to CEASE.

PARER (Rhyme for Tom Lehrer /'lɛrər/) — Counterpart to ERROR.

Down

SCRAP (____yard; scrapyard is a common sci-fi setting) — Counterpart to SPACE.

THETA (It goes something like this: Ꮎ) — Counterpart to CORER.

RIGOR (Feature of liturgy, often; strictness/adherence to rubrics) — Counterpart to ALTAR.

INANE (It's vacuous, in a sense) — Counterpart to LASSO.

PALER (Fino is paler than Pedro Ximénez sherry) — Counterpart to DRYER.

Re: Holes (1970) [pdf]

#16
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know that one, but here's a superficially similar joke from somewhere among http://miresperanto.com/humuro.htm : When the British government invited commercial proposals for the digging of the Channel Tunnel between England and France, one man submitted a bid for only £10,000. “How can you possibly dig under the English Channel for only £10,000?” asked the project manager. “It’s simple,” replied the low bidde…

An answer to your puzzle in another post that is locked: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42498953 The "alternate" 5x5 word square that satisfies all the clues without using the words from the first grid is: S T R I P C H I N A R E G A L A T O N E P A R E R Breakdown of the solution: Across STRIP (Remove the outer layer of, perhaps) — Counterpart to SCALD. CHINA (Region on a globe) — Counterpart to POLAR. REGAL (…

Yep, you got it! :)
Post reply on HN