Live data from Hacker News

Ryanair flight landed at Manchester airport with six minutes of fuel left

theguardian.com

11–20 of 586 posts

Re: Ryanair flight landed at Manchester airport with six minutes of fuel left

#11
post #8

> The pilots had been taking passengers from Pisa in Italy to Prestwick in Scotland on Friday evening, but wind speeds of up to 100mph meant they were unable to land. > After three failed attempts to touch down, the pilots of Ryanair flight FR3418 issued a mayday emergency call and raced to Manchester, where the weather was calmer. #1 - if Prestwick had wind speeds up to 100mph, then why the h*ll was the airport not…

Looks like the third attempt was actually in Edinburgh

Re: Ryanair flight landed at Manchester airport with six minutes of fuel left

#13
post #8

> The pilots had been taking passengers from Pisa in Italy to Prestwick in Scotland on Friday evening, but wind speeds of up to 100mph meant they were unable to land. > After three failed attempts to touch down, the pilots of Ryanair flight FR3418 issued a mayday emergency call and raced to Manchester, where the weather was calmer. #1 - if Prestwick had wind speeds up to 100mph, then why the h*ll was the airport not…

The third attempted landing was in their diversion airport, Edinburgh, not a third at Prestwick.

Re: Ryanair flight landed at Manchester airport with six minutes of fuel left

#14
post #8

> The pilots had been taking passengers from Pisa in Italy to Prestwick in Scotland on Friday evening, but wind speeds of up to 100mph meant they were unable to land. > After three failed attempts to touch down, the pilots of Ryanair flight FR3418 issued a mayday emergency call and raced to Manchester, where the weather was calmer. #1 - if Prestwick had wind speeds up to 100mph, then why the h*ll was the airport not…

The third attempt was in Edinburgh, looks like.

Re: Ryanair flight landed at Manchester airport with six minutes of fuel left

#15
post #3

Looks like they tried two attempts to land in Prestwick over two hours, then flew to Edinburgh and made one aborted landing, then finally went to Manchester. What a nerve wracking experience for those pilots. I wonder if on the final attempt they knew they had to force it down no matter what.

About 5 years ago before ATC recordings became mainstay on YouTube, there was an American pilot that declared an emergency at JFK and very firmly said "we are turning back and landing NOW. Get the aircraft OFF all runways".

He was low in fuel and also frustrated with Kennedy ATC because he declared "minimum fuel" earlier and was still getting vectored around. (I know "minimum fuel" is not an emergency and has a very precise meaning).

They must have been very close to running out. But it was a valuable lesson learned in speaking up before you get to that point.

Re: Ryanair flight landed at Manchester airport with six minutes of fuel left

#16

Between overworked, understaffed ATC and undertrained pilots, I'm expecting some major disasters in the coming years.

One of the problems with modern internet discourse is there is an implicit assumption that the problem of one country is automatically the problem of another country.

Re: Ryanair flight landed at Manchester airport with six minutes of fuel left

#18

Between overworked, understaffed ATC and undertrained pilots, I'm expecting some major disasters in the coming years.

One of the problems with modern internet discourse is there is an implicit assumption that the problem of one country is automatically the problem of another country.

Flights operate internationally?

Re: Ryanair flight landed at Manchester airport with six minutes of fuel left

#19
post #3

Looks like they tried two attempts to land in Prestwick over two hours, then flew to Edinburgh and made one aborted landing, then finally went to Manchester. What a nerve wracking experience for those pilots. I wonder if on the final attempt they knew they had to force it down no matter what.

Assuming it wasn't just luck, it seems impressive they managed to maximize their (landing attempts/fuel reserves) ratio like that.

It is a requirement [1] to land with 45 minutes of fuel remaining, if the pilots go under that, it is considered an incident. As soon as estimated landing fuel goes under the limit, the flight needs to declare an emergency (as was done in this case).

[1]: https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-14/chapter-I/subchapter-F... is the US rule, EASA has a similar rule.

Re: Ryanair flight landed at Manchester airport with six minutes of fuel left

#20
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One of the problems with modern internet discourse is there is an implicit assumption that the problem of one country is automatically the problem of another country.

Flights operate internationally?

Yes, between other countries without having to go via the US!
Post reply on HN