Live data from Hacker News

How we are building Audacity 4

youtube.com

11–20 of 35 posts

Re: How we are building Audacity 4

#11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

GPL doesn't guarantee you security in any way, shape, or form nor is a privacy policy.

Sure and I agree. However Reddit is sometimes a source of sensational misunderstanding, fear, uncertainty, doubt and misinformation.

Who said anything about reddit?

Re: How we are building Audacity 4

#12
post #2

I know accessibility for low vision users was mentioned, but I wonder, with all these changes, whether version 4 will be accessible to screen reader users, and if so, whether any major features will nevertheless remain inaccessible.

We're using the framework my team on MuseScore Studio created for the UI in Audacity. This allows us to port over the significant amount of screen reader support we built over there too.

We'll need to spend time making sure it's applying correctly to every corner of the app - but when it's done, the app will be far more broadly supported than V3.

Re: How we are building Audacity 4

#13
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The code is GPL. https://github.com/audacity/audacity The application privacy policy is here https://www.audacityteam.org/desktop-privacy-notice/

GPL doesn't guarantee you security in any way, shape, or form nor is a privacy policy.

You're right. Neither of these things are proof of honesty but to be clear, I would never work on a project that collects or misuses user data. This isn’t really a matter of “taking my word for it,” either. If anything like that were happening, it would be visible in the codebase, which anyone can look through (and many have). The app simply can’t transmit data without explicit instructions in the code.

Audacity does not store any personal information of any kind, and never did.

Re: How we are building Audacity 4

#15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

GPL doesn't guarantee you security in any way, shape, or form nor is a privacy policy.

Sure and I agree. However Reddit is sometimes a source of sensational misunderstanding, fear, uncertainty, doubt and misinformation.

It’s amazing how much you are avoiding the question.

Re: How we are building Audacity 4

#17
post #8

I don’t know when it happened, but earlier in the week a non-tech member of staff, who was trying to install Audacity, called me really confused because it was asking about installing and then saving to some sort of cloud storage that was being pushed during the installation process. I personally haven’t used Audacity for a couple of years, so the cloud storage stuff added in 2024 is new to me showing up during insta…

I think Musehub.com is a sister project within Muse Group that helps mitigate the cost of paying professional developers to work on Audacity and MuseScore. In the case of Muse Score it also provides a marketplace for third parties. I don’t use it but I can see why it exists…ordinary folks expect cloud services these days. And if I had a different use case, it would help me get stuff done. But for what it’s worth with…

Yes. And ?

A lot of projects propose cloud storage without trying to force it on you. More the How than the What which is questionable here.

Re: How we are building Audacity 4

#18
post #17
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think Musehub.com is a sister project within Muse Group that helps mitigate the cost of paying professional developers to work on Audacity and MuseScore. In the case of Muse Score it also provides a marketplace for third parties. I don’t use it but I can see why it exists…ordinary folks expect cloud services these days. And if I had a different use case, it would help me get stuff done. But for what it’s worth with…

Yes. And ? A lot of projects propose cloud storage without trying to force it on you. More the How than the What which is questionable here.

Like I said for many people, it is a benefit not a detriment.

Add in all the people who just don’t care and there is only a relative handful of people who are bothered.

Now filter out the people who don’t use the software from that relative handful and there’s an actual handful of users who might have to find something else because everything isn’t for everyone.

Re: How we are building Audacity 4

#19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure and I agree. However Reddit is sometimes a source of sensational misunderstanding, fear, uncertainty, doubt and misinformation.

Who said anything about reddit?

The claim of Russian involvement was a link to HN comments on a link to a Reddit thread.

Re: How we are building Audacity 4

#20

I don’t know when it happened, but earlier in the week a non-tech member of staff, who was trying to install Audacity, called me really confused because it was asking about installing and then saving to some sort of cloud storage that was being pushed during the installation process. I personally haven’t used Audacity for a couple of years, so the cloud storage stuff added in 2024 is new to me showing up during insta…

There were some forks of the original at the time that are still simple like https://tenacityaudio.org/ but I'm not sure how healthy any of them are.
Post reply on HN