Live data from Hacker News

PortalVR: XR Without a Headset

portalvr.io

11–20 of 20 posts

Re: PortalVR: XR Without a Headset

#11

Why would you name a gaming adjacent system “PortalVR”? I doubt you’ll get in trouble for it but you’re going to confuse so many Portal fans (and there are a lot of them).

Portal is pretty old at this point. And realistically you can only expect to get dibs on a generic word for so long.

Re: PortalVR: XR Without a Headset

#12

Why would you name a gaming adjacent system “PortalVR”? I doubt you’ll get in trouble for it but you’re going to confuse so many Portal fans (and there are a lot of them).

Portal is pretty old at this point. And realistically you can only expect to get dibs on a generic word for so long.

Sure it's just bizarre for me as a dedicated Portal fan. I just replayed Portal 2 a year ago so it's still fresh for me.

If they're truly attached to it they shouldn't change now of course.

Re: PortalVR: XR Without a Headset

#13
post #6

Why would you name a gaming adjacent system “PortalVR”? I doubt you’ll get in trouble for it but you’re going to confuse so many Portal fans (and there are a lot of them).

I was going to name it Portal, but I named it PortalVR to minimize confusion. It’s called PortalVR because there is no better name to describe what it’s like to play VR this way. It is like playing games by looking through a portal you hold in your hand.

Yeah please don't change this based on the thoughts of just one Portal fan. If you like the name, keep it.

Re: PortalVR: XR Without a Headset

#14

Why would you name a gaming adjacent system “PortalVR”? I doubt you’ll get in trouble for it but you’re going to confuse so many Portal fans (and there are a lot of them).

It's a pretty common word and the last real portal game was 14 years ago. I don't think it's that confusing.

And there's already a VR headset named Portal that's not confusing those fans.

Though uh that one has some potential for confusion.

Re: PortalVR: XR Without a Headset

#15

Why would you name a gaming adjacent system “PortalVR”? I doubt you’ll get in trouble for it but you’re going to confuse so many Portal fans (and there are a lot of them).

It's a pretty common word and the last real portal game was 14 years ago. I don't think it's that confusing. And there's already a VR headset named Portal that's not confusing those fans. Though uh that one has some potential for confusion.

Nope the last was released 9 years ago and it was ironically a VR-only game: https://store.steampowered.com/app/446750/Portal_Stories_VR/

Re: PortalVR: XR Without a Headset

#16

Why doesn't the QR code take you to the official app. Or just provide links to them. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=io.portalvr.co...

That’s not the main app, that’s the controller app you install on a phone to use with the main app. The main app must be side loaded, because Google will not approve it in the Play store since it installs third party apps.

Re: PortalVR: XR Without a Headset

#17
post #8

This would be pretty cool for a Descent clone, since the game is all about 6 degrees of freedom moving your tablet around to fly through a space would feel pretty natural. Where this fails however is that it doesn’t seem to track the user’s face in order to properly render a parallax effect, so it does not really feel like a true portal.

I tried that and it made the gameplay worse since it harmed your ability to control the camera precisely with your hand. The goal of this is primarily to enable gameplay, and secondarily to deliver a portal effect.

Re: PortalVR: XR Without a Headset

#18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a pretty common word and the last real portal game was 14 years ago. I don't think it's that confusing. And there's already a VR headset named Portal that's not confusing those fans. Though uh that one has some potential for confusion.

Nope the last was released 9 years ago and it was ironically a VR-only game: https://store.steampowered.com/app/446750/Portal_Stories_VR/

That is at least officially a mod for portal 2, and also it's not by Valve. It doesn't count as a real portal game.

Re: PortalVR: XR Without a Headset

#19

Why would you name a gaming adjacent system “PortalVR”? I doubt you’ll get in trouble for it but you’re going to confuse so many Portal fans (and there are a lot of them).

It's a pretty common word and the last real portal game was 14 years ago. I don't think it's that confusing. And there's already a VR headset named Portal that's not confusing those fans. Though uh that one has some potential for confusion.

Three years ago in a very real sense https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aperture_Desk_Job

Re: PortalVR: XR Without a Headset

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a pretty common word and the last real portal game was 14 years ago. I don't think it's that confusing. And there's already a VR headset named Portal that's not confusing those fans. Though uh that one has some potential for confusion.

Three years ago in a very real sense https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aperture_Desk_Job

I put "real" in my sentence explicitly to exclude these little control demos. Half an hour long, no portals, whatever sense it's a "very real" portal game is getting outvoted by the other senses.
Post reply on HN