Live data from Hacker News

AI tools I wish existed

sharif.io

11–20 of 112 posts

Re: AI tools I wish existed

#11
post #2

For me: A local model to plug in to Apple photos to look for metadata inconsistencies in my photo librar, add missing location information, add dates from those old scanned photos with the date on the corner.

This seems like a relatively easy thing to code oneself, or for someone to have already made somewhere (relatively easy, just writing something for yourself command line doing it, assuming you can spend a work week of nights [worst case, based on my working with images in folders in the past I think 10 hours for something that works, reasonable time for coffee and other breaks])

For you maybe, we are engaging with the left side of the bell curve never forget that.

Also use simpler words.

Re: AI tools I wish existed

#12
I would love for my phone keyboard (Swiftkey) to use a locally-running Voxtral for speech-to-text (bonus points if it can use the NPU of the Snapdragon SoC).

The voice recognition capabilities of Google Speech Services, which is what the mic button hooks into, suck. Meanwhile, Voxtral (and Whisper) understand what I'm trying to say far better, they automatically "edit out" any stuttering or stammering that I might have, and they properly capitalize and include punctuation. And they handle being bilingual exceedingly well, including, for example, using English words in the middle of French sentences.

The best solution I could find so far is this F-Droid app that uses Whisper : https://f-droid.org/en/packages/org.woheller69.whisperplus/

But it has some downsides. First, I have to manually switch to that different keyboard; thankfully my Samsung phone offers an easy switch shortcut any time a keyboard is on screen, so it only requires 3 taps... and thankfully it's smart enough to send me back to Swiftkey once it's done. Second, only 30 seconds... sometimes I ramble on for longer. Third, the way it's designed kind of sucks: you either have to hold a button (even though the point of speech-to-text is that I don't have to hold anything down) or let automatic detection end the recording and start processing, in which case it often cuts me off if I take more than 1 second thinking about my next words.

This is arguably one of the biggest use cases of modern AI technology and the least controversial one; phones have the hardware necessary to do it all locally, too! And yet... I couldn't find a better offering than this.

(Bonus points for anyone working on speech-to-text: give me a quick shortcut to add the string "[(microphone emoji)]" in my messages just to let the other party know that this was transcribed, so that they know to overlook possible mistakes.)

Re: AI tools I wish existed

#13
Not just for this article, but from most ideas/articles around LLMs, I feel like they aren't "thinking with portals" enough. We have "portal gun" tech (or at least, that's what's being marketed), and we're using it as better doors.

Re: AI tools I wish existed

#14
A recommendation engine that looks at my browsing history, sees what blog posts or articles I spent the most time on, then searches the web every night for things I should be reading that I’m not.

This kind of exists in the form of ChatGPT Pulse. It uses your ChatGPT history rather than your browser history, but that's probably just as good a source for people interested in using it (e.g. people who use ChatGPT enough to want it to recommend things to them.) https://openai.com/index/introducing-chatgpt-pulse/

Re: AI tools I wish existed

#15
There's some sort of fundamental category mistake going on with thinking like this.

Most of the items in this list fall prey to it, but it is maybe best exemplified by this one:

> A writing app that lets you “request a critique” from a bunch of famous writers. What would Hemingway say about this blog post? What did he find confusing? What did he like?

Any app that ever claimed to tell you what "Hemingway would say about this blog post" would evidently be lying — it'd be giving you what that specific AI model generates in response to such a prompt. 100 models would give you 100 answers, and none of them could claim to actually "say what Hemingway would've said". It's not as if Hemingway's entire personality and outlooks are losslessly encoded into the few hundreds of thousands of words of writing/speech transcripts we have from him, and can be reconstructed by a sufficiently beefy LLM.

So in effect it becomes an exercise of "can you fool the human into thinking this is a plausible thing Hemingway would've said".

The reason why you would care to hear Hemingway's thought on your writing, or Steve Jobs' thoughts on your UI design, is precisely because they are the flesh-and-bone, embodied versions of themselves. Anything else is like trying to eat a picture of a sandwich to satisfy your hunger.

There's something unsettling that so many people cannot seem to cut clearly through this illusion.

Re: AI tools I wish existed

#16

>A recommendation engine that looks at my browsing history, sees what blog posts or articles I spent the most time on, then searches the web every night for things I should be reading that I’m not. In the morning I should get a digest of links I don't understand why Google, Brave, or Mozilla are not building this. This already exists in a centralized form like X's timeline for posts, but it could exist for the entire…

I wouldn’t trust a random app with my browser history and majority of population wouldn’t either.

Chrome, Brave, and Firefox already have your browser history.

Re: AI tools I wish existed

#17

>A recommendation engine that looks at my browsing history, sees what blog posts or articles I spent the most time on, then searches the web every night for things I should be reading that I’m not. In the morning I should get a digest of links I don't understand why Google, Brave, or Mozilla are not building this. This already exists in a centralized form like X's timeline for posts, but it could exist for the entire…

Sounds a bit similar to ChatGPT Pulse.

Re: AI tools I wish existed

#18

> A minimalist ebook reader that lets me read ebooks, but I can highlight passages and have the model explain things in more depth off to the side. It should also take on the persona of the author. It should feel like an extension of the book and not a separate chat instance. Isn’t this just a chrome extension that sends data back and forth with chat gpt token?

It’s easy to implement on a computer, but I think they want it built into a kindle.

Re: AI tools I wish existed

#19

>A recommendation engine that looks at my browsing history, sees what blog posts or articles I spent the most time on, then searches the web every night for things I should be reading that I’m not. In the morning I should get a digest of links I don't understand why Google, Brave, or Mozilla are not building this. This already exists in a centralized form like X's timeline for posts, but it could exist for the entire…

this doesnt even need AI to do really, and was an intrinsic part of the idea behind hyperlinking dating all the way back to Bush' memex (1940s)

Re: AI tools I wish existed

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This seems like a relatively easy thing to code oneself, or for someone to have already made somewhere (relatively easy, just writing something for yourself command line doing it, assuming you can spend a work week of nights [worst case, based on my working with images in folders in the past I think 10 hours for something that works, reasonable time for coffee and other breaks])

For you maybe, we are engaging with the left side of the bell curve never forget that. Also use simpler words.

Yeah, there are probably a few multimillion dollar app ideas in here, but of insufficient complexity or lowbrow-ness for the typical HN reader (myself included). The nano-banana template idea or the Q&A Walkman, for example.
Post reply on HN