Live data from Hacker News

Why does AI feel so different?

blog.nilenso.com

11–20 of 105 posts

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#11

It’s the first revolutionary technology that his first goal is to make money for VC investors instead of really change the world, the perceived benefit for society is just a sub-product of the ponzi scheme behind those VC firms.

What's your proof?

I recommend this Better Offline episode:

https://www.wheresyoured.at/the-haters-gui/

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#12

It’s the first revolutionary technology that his first goal is to make money for VC investors instead of really change the world, the perceived benefit for society is just a sub-product of the ponzi scheme behind those VC firms.

What's your proof?

Literally every business school and consulting firm wrote articles about how many jobs this stuff was going to displace and how much it would grow the gdp by.

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#13
"Ah cool a list of historic technologies that caused a paradigm shift... I wonder what second-order effects are to be expected from generative AI!"

> Customer service automation, Agentic coding, Content creation

Fucking hell. Customer service automation. Auto-spaghetti code. Brainrot as a service. Truly what society needs.

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#14

The article keeps referring to "AI" as if it's a coherent, agreed-upon thing. It's not. "AI" is a marketing term that's been applied to whatever happens to look impressive at the moment---right now, that's LLMs. There's no settled definition, no unified discipline, and lumping everything from generative text models to actual robotics under the same label just obscures the discussion. If we're talking about LLMs, let'…

I encourage you to try and really lean on LLMs (Claude Code in particular), it's hard to argue that there is no productivity boost. Athropy in "low level" skills is certainly real though. But our ancestors knew how to repair a pair of socks. Due to industrialisation, we just buy new ones and have lost the skills to repair them. Most people may forget how to do many things in programming, but may still intimately understand, at a high level, what each line is doing.

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#15
post #9

This strikes me as babbling. 70 percent fever dream. To take one example, the author speaks of using AI to chat with his favorite thinkers. Well I have favorite thinkers, so why don’t I chat with AI versions of them? Because I know it’s all fake. Whatever substance there is to chatting with a corpse or corpus is unknowable. So it amounts to playing with dolls. I think for a living. I would LIKE AI to help. But it doe…

The thinking-averse outnumber the thinking-inclined. They've tried this thinking thing, and want nothing to do with it. They all went to public school, after all, and the rare times thinking happened it was painful and had to be forced upon them. Their ideal of Being is to react to content, experience positive emotional immediacy, or dull their intellects: all feeling, no thinking. They'll win in the short term, due…

It's a negative-sum game that breaks the fourth wall; even not playing makes you lose.

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#16
AI feels different because quietly we are all aware, to differing degrees of comfort, that the world around us is collapsing. We see the escalating effects of climate change impacting day-to-day life in ways we were told would only happen in the far future, witnessing genocide become a normal part of the news critique of which can mean serious personal consequences, we're watching the United States transform into State Capitalism [0] making our country far more like modern day China than many of us would have ever imagined possible.

And we deeply need to believe something wonderous, whether delightful or terrifying, is also happening. I honestly think AI is largely mass hallucination which is supported by a system that is able to extract tremendous wealth from this hallucination continuing.

We can no longer believe that everything happening is normal, so we need to inject some, slightly less horrific, explanation for what we're experiencing.

0. https://www.wsj.com/economy/the-u-s-marches-toward-state-cap...

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#17
These are poor examples: > Why do I need to know what quarks are, or how steam engines work? Why do I need to know anything about anything? I can just look it up with AI

Literally all possible with Google and YouTube.

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#18
post #14

The article keeps referring to "AI" as if it's a coherent, agreed-upon thing. It's not. "AI" is a marketing term that's been applied to whatever happens to look impressive at the moment---right now, that's LLMs. There's no settled definition, no unified discipline, and lumping everything from generative text models to actual robotics under the same label just obscures the discussion. If we're talking about LLMs, let'…

I encourage you to try and really lean on LLMs (Claude Code in particular), it's hard to argue that there is no productivity boost. Athropy in "low level" skills is certainly real though. But our ancestors knew how to repair a pair of socks. Due to industrialisation, we just buy new ones and have lost the skills to repair them. Most people may forget how to do many things in programming, but may still intimately unde…

The more you use it and the deeper you go the more you realise its limitations as a useful software engineering tool and more as an autocomplete.

Is it useful ? Yes? Am I happy it exists yes ? Is it revolutionary. I doubt it.

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#19

The article keeps referring to "AI" as if it's a coherent, agreed-upon thing. It's not. "AI" is a marketing term that's been applied to whatever happens to look impressive at the moment---right now, that's LLMs. There's no settled definition, no unified discipline, and lumping everything from generative text models to actual robotics under the same label just obscures the discussion. If we're talking about LLMs, let'…

Personally I now get my work done in half the time and spend the rest of my newfound time with my family. It’s gonna be hard to convince me that isn’t a fantastic productivity increase.

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#20
post #9

This strikes me as babbling. 70 percent fever dream. To take one example, the author speaks of using AI to chat with his favorite thinkers. Well I have favorite thinkers, so why don’t I chat with AI versions of them? Because I know it’s all fake. Whatever substance there is to chatting with a corpse or corpus is unknowable. So it amounts to playing with dolls. I think for a living. I would LIKE AI to help. But it doe…

The thinking-averse outnumber the thinking-inclined. They've tried this thinking thing, and want nothing to do with it. They all went to public school, after all, and the rare times thinking happened it was painful and had to be forced upon them. Their ideal of Being is to react to content, experience positive emotional immediacy, or dull their intellects: all feeling, no thinking. They'll win in the short term, due…

They all went to public school?
Post reply on HN