Live data from Hacker News

Israel relying on Microsoft cloud for expansive surveillance of Palestinians

theguardian.com

11–20 of 57 posts

Re: Israel relying on Microsoft cloud for expansive surveillance of Palestinians

#12

Today it's Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank. Tomorrow it's you.

Its already you, but capitalism. It'll be this soon enough if republicanism continues.

Capitalism is just a reflection of people being self-interested which you can't prevent without being authoritarian which will inevitably leads also to surveillance.

Re: Israel relying on Microsoft cloud for expansive surveillance of Palestinians

#13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In the context of surveillance or in the context of a genocide ?! I must assume you mean the first one, because Israel would not survive without the US

North Korea survives just fine without the US. Nukes are enough.

[flagged]

Re: Israel relying on Microsoft cloud for expansive surveillance of Palestinians

#14
post #11

this will probably get flagged in a couple of hours

Was already flagged. I vouched it and it became unflagged. Now it's flagged again...

(I don't think every story about this conflict should be on HN by the way, as a "major on-going topic". But IMHO this particular story seemed like a good one as it intersects with tech and is something actually new, at least to some degree).

Re: Israel relying on Microsoft cloud for expansive surveillance of Palestinians

#15

Today it's Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank. Tomorrow it's you.

Its already you, but capitalism. It'll be this soon enough if republicanism continues.

It's scary how this is actually being called out as a problem of capitalism ... when anyone can look up history and see communists were actually doing this in 1946. Not just phones, they were doing it on the street, going as far as sending out people to listen in on conversations everywhere. Makes sense, I guess: there were barely any phones to tap when communists started doing this.

In case you don't know mass phone tapping didn't start in the US until decades (plural) later.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_surveillance_in_East_Germ...

Not that I have experienced socialists/communists reacting positively to being proven wrong much before. Even when proven wrong by their own historical record (yes, they PROUDLY published they were doing this in 1946, after all, that's what Marx instructed them to do). Yes, the need for mass surveillance of the masses is actually in Marx and Engels's work.

In fact it was a part of Marx's work in much the same way as you are arguing it here: he was falsely accusing capitalist and bourgeoisie of mass surveillance, even while he was trying to do it himself. But yeah, Marx is Marx. His whole work, a pamphlet discussing massacring the bourgeoisie ... when, of course, both he himself and his family (up and down, his parents, he himself, his wife, his children) were very much part of the "hated" bourgeoisie. But, of course, in his mind he was excluded. He himself was very much not the evil he was trying to fight, and that every description he published said otherwise ... Very on-brand for communists, that.

Re: Israel relying on Microsoft cloud for expansive surveillance of Palestinians

#16
In the documentary (in the form of cinéma vérité) The Act of Killing (1), the director learnt about "anti-communist" massacres in 1965 Indonesia, which was sanctioned by a regime whose successors were still in power in the modern times. He compared the atmosphere of the country as if he came to Germany 40 years after WW2, but with the Nazis having won it. He talks to some of the killers, and he found them not even regretful, but boastful - throughout the documentary, he learns that if they admitted they were wrong, they'd be having to admit to themselves that they murdered a lot of innocent people, so they'd rather construct a fantasy world where they're the good guys.

There's even a musical segment of the documentary (he convinced the people to reimagine their doings in the style of 50's Hollywood movies they loved) where actors playing the victims thank the killers for saving them from godlessness and sending them to heaven: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o-ta9To14yw

I wonder how many of the genocide-defenders and genocide-enablers (not to mention genocide-executioners) will have similar PTSD...

1) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4kJZb2Q1NmE

Re: Israel relying on Microsoft cloud for expansive surveillance of Palestinians

#17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Its already you, but capitalism. It'll be this soon enough if republicanism continues.

Capitalism is just a reflection of people being self-interested which you can't prevent without being authoritarian which will inevitably leads also to surveillance.

> Capitalism is just a reflection of people being self-interested

I don't think that's the case. I think most people are not self-interested, or at least not in the selfish sense. I think most people are more than willing to sacrifice _some_ direct personal gain for better community gains.

The problem is that capitalism only allows selfish self-interest to flourish, so it incentivises even the more community-oriented people to always put themselves first, a lot of the time even in detriment to their immediate vicinity.

Capitalism is a form of authoritarianism in that it really only serves a few, and everyone else is just constantly fighting for survival.

> being authoritarian which will inevitably leads also to surveillance

That's exactly where capitalism is taking us.

Re: Israel relying on Microsoft cloud for expansive surveillance of Palestinians

#19
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Its already you, but capitalism. It'll be this soon enough if republicanism continues.

It's scary how this is actually being called out as a problem of capitalism ... when anyone can look up history and see communists were actually doing this in 1946. Not just phones, they were doing it on the street, going as far as sending out people to listen in on conversations everywhere. Makes sense, I guess: there were barely any phones to tap when communists started doing this. In case you don't know mass phone…

I would really much want to see which Marx (with Engels or not) writings advocate for mass surveillance. I would also like to see a reference of when did he call for a bourgeoisie massacre.
Post reply on HN