Live data from Hacker News

Web fingerprinting is worse than I thought (2023)

bitestring.com

11–20 of 219 posts

Re: Web fingerprinting is worse than I thought (2023)

#11
post #3

Isn't fingerprinting covered by GDPR in a similar way to how cookies are? So in theory you should be able to opt out, at least as an EU user.

sure, if they ask you can we track you and you say no they should not fingerprint.

How would you ever find out/enforce this though? With cookies, you can examine the local cookie storage but with fingerprinting everything happens server-side (as I understand).

Re: Web fingerprinting is worse than I thought (2023)

#12
post #3

Isn't fingerprinting covered by GDPR in a similar way to how cookies are? So in theory you should be able to opt out, at least as an EU user.

Those obnoxious "cookie" dialogs? Yes, they cover fingerprinting as well. E.g. some innocent company wants to keep your precise geolocation data for 12 years: https://x.com/dmitriid/status/1817122117093056541

Cookie banners were never about cookies or privacy. The industry designed them with some very explicit goals in mind: to force users to opt-in to pervasive tracking, and to blame "how unusable web has become" on GDPR

Re: Web fingerprinting is worse than I thought (2023)

#16
post #9

Browser fingerprinting is one of those things that should be outright illegal - it is far more of a threat than tracking cookies ever were. But it hasn't permeated the public consciousness like cookies have, so regulators seem to ignore it.

Seems almost impossible to police though.

Re: Web fingerprinting is worse than I thought (2023)

#17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

sure, if they ask you can we track you and you say no they should not fingerprint.

EU (or whoever) could mandate a switch in the browser, when turned on, all identifying apis are disabled. But the IP is still the same, so..

The law has been around for almost 10 years now. If browser vendors wanted, they could have come up with such a switch themselves.

Guess which company is coincidentally is the world's largest advertiser, largest ad broker, largest data tracker and owns world's most popular browser?

Re: Web fingerprinting is worse than I thought (2023)

#19
post #9

Browser fingerprinting is one of those things that should be outright illegal - it is far more of a threat than tracking cookies ever were. But it hasn't permeated the public consciousness like cookies have, so regulators seem to ignore it.

We need regulators with more balls. And more brains. This privacy theater is becoming very painful to watch.

Re: Web fingerprinting is worse than I thought (2023)

#20
post #9

Browser fingerprinting is one of those things that should be outright illegal - it is far more of a threat than tracking cookies ever were. But it hasn't permeated the public consciousness like cookies have, so regulators seem to ignore it.

Or... You could read GDPR and realize that "cookie dialogs" were never about cookies: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44670345
Post reply on HN