Live data from Hacker News

'Gwada negative': French scientists find new blood type in woman

lemonde.fr

11–20 of 76 posts

Re: 'Gwada negative': French scientists find new blood type in woman

#13
post #3
post #2

The OP is low on details. There is more in this article (in french): https://www.lindependant.fr/2025/06/21/il-ny-a-quelle-qui-es... Apparently the ISBT have added this to their list: https://www.isbtweb.org/isbt-working-parties/rcibgt.html (the page still says 47 but the data tables have it added)

Neither article talks about whether this is a minor or a major antigen. Blood for transfusion needs to be crossmatched against antigen types of the recipient. Many patients will tolerate several transfusions of a minor mismatched antigen before developing a sensitivity. Major antigens are what cause significant reactions that can be life-threatening. Minor antigens come into play when crossmatching for infants and pr…

That's interesting; I didn't know that to realize it was missing.

Re: 'Gwada negative': French scientists find new blood type in woman

#14
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Still more reasonable than basing your entire personality on the month you were born.

[flagged]

That's where correlations of random events and placebo end and where discovery begins.

There are 'gods' that are 'better' than others. Even if the principle of what you/people believe goes against what you find scientifically relevent, or factual, or sensible. There still is something to be said about a group of people following a strange set of rules that could be demonstrably better than other sets of rules and beliefs. May it be enviromental, genetic, placebo or a tiny edge over what gives life meaning. We ended up with the gods we have today, not by coincidence, but because all the other ones failed their followers.

Re: 'Gwada negative': French scientists find new blood type in woman

#16
post #6
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Neither article talks about whether this is a minor or a major antigen. Blood for transfusion needs to be crossmatched against antigen types of the recipient. Many patients will tolerate several transfusions of a minor mismatched antigen before developing a sensitivity. Major antigens are what cause significant reactions that can be life-threatening. Minor antigens come into play when crossmatching for infants and pr…

I recently had major surgery and got two units of blood in during the operation and two more post-op. Post-op before I got the blood, they typed my blood again, and a nurse stayed in the room while I got the blood and I wondered why. This comment makes it clear.

Close observation for 15 minutes is typical for any blood transfusion. You do a set of pre-transfusion vitals, vitals when the blood hits the vein, vitals every 5 minutes until 15 minutes is up, vitals every 15 minutes until the blood is done. Ask any nurse why they hate running blood.

Depending on the severity of the reaction, blood will either be stopped or the patient will be loaded up with Benadryl and Tylenol with the blood running at a slower rate.

Re: 'Gwada negative': French scientists find new blood type in woman

#18
post #5

[flagged]

I remember reading something about peoples personalities being vaguely related to their names which makes even less sense. Unless peoples names subtlety influence their behavior. Perhaps if these blood type ideas are so prevalent in Korea and everyone from a very young age is aware of their blood type they might have a self fulfilling prophecy.

Re: 'Gwada negative': French scientists find new blood type in woman

#19
post #11
post #5

[flagged]

Well, it's definitely true to some extent, since there will 100% be some genes that contribute in some way to a person's personality that are colocated with genes responsible for blood type.

It's pseudoscience, nothing more.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_type_personality_theory

Re: 'Gwada negative': French scientists find new blood type in woman

#20
post #5

[flagged]

I remember reading something about peoples personalities being vaguely related to their names which makes even less sense. Unless peoples names subtlety influence their behavior. Perhaps if these blood type ideas are so prevalent in Korea and everyone from a very young age is aware of their blood type they might have a self fulfilling prophecy.

https://www.msn.com/en-us/lifestyle/family/father-names-both...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nominative_determinism

Post reply on HN