Live data from Hacker News

A Postmortem of a Startup

buildwithtract.com

11–20 of 132 posts

Re: A Postmortem of a Startup

#11
post #3

A good question to ask before starting a startup is : "Do I see myself working 10 years on this problem?". Looks like they ran out of steam, rather than out of runway.

Why 10 years? Is it not typical with startup founders to plan a lucrative exit in a much shorter time frame?

No, where did you get this idea? Good startups do not think this way.

Re: A Postmortem of a Startup

#12
This is interesting and they make some good observations but I can't help but think the deck was stacked against them because they are trying to come up with a technical/business solution to what is fundamentally a political problem.

Re: A Postmortem of a Startup

#13
well written. I think your fatal mistake even though you folks are smart was not understanding the complete value chain of your business.

What I mean by understanding the economics of the value chain is you've to understand how your customers make money, how their customers make money & how their suppliers make money. From there - you can workout your value proposition - are you saving your customers money (means there's a cap on how much value you can extract) or are you allowing your customers to make more money (how much value you can extract is kinda uncapped - depending on mechanics)

The other mistake - which you correctly kinda alluded to is not understanding the incentives / dynamics of the industry. UK land is tricky since most wealth / power is packed into UK land. hence your part about emotion etc.

final mistake was equating success to raising money. Profit, if not revenue growth is the only measure of success. Raising money is not.

Re: A Postmortem of a Startup

#14
post #4

Thanks for writing this! > Housing in Britain is expensive because getting planning permission is difficult. Isn't the real problem that supply is artificially constrained because house prices and the economy are interlinked in a way in a special way in the UK economy, such that the majority of home owners don't want it changed (because more supply == downward pricing pressure) I think the only entity that could mean…

It looks like this startup tried to hack the system by streamlining one of the key mechanisms of artificial constraint: the difficulty of getting permits.

Not a fundamental cure, of course, but it sounds like a promising hack to squeeze out a few more building permits than would otherwise have been issued.

Re: A Postmortem of a Startup

#15
post #4

Thanks for writing this! > Housing in Britain is expensive because getting planning permission is difficult. Isn't the real problem that supply is artificially constrained because house prices and the economy are interlinked in a way in a special way in the UK economy, such that the majority of home owners don't want it changed (because more supply == downward pricing pressure) I think the only entity that could mean…

One of the ways in which supply is artificially restricted is that getting planning permission is difficult, so you’re not actually disagreeing with OP

Re: A Postmortem of a Startup

#16

This is interesting and they make some good observations but I can't help but think the deck was stacked against them because they are trying to come up with a technical/business solution to what is fundamentally a political problem.

Yeah "founded to build software to fix Britain’s housing crisis."

There was literally zero hope for success.

Re: A Postmortem of a Startup

#17

>> After raising a £744,000 pre-seed round in April 2024, we explored several business models Capital after traction

to those who cry about 'BS' like diversity etc ask yourself if people without the same backgrounds, looks would have been able to raise the same amount without a business model.

Re: A Postmortem of a Startup

#18
post #7
post #4

Thanks for writing this! > Housing in Britain is expensive because getting planning permission is difficult. Isn't the real problem that supply is artificially constrained because house prices and the economy are interlinked in a way in a special way in the UK economy, such that the majority of home owners don't want it changed (because more supply == downward pricing pressure) I think the only entity that could mean…

I think you're describing NIMBY, which is more of a US/SF thing (but also is a case in Europe to some extent).

NIMBY is an universal human concept, it's present everywhere - Europe, Asia, South America. It may come in different flavours but it's everywhere. People don't welcome changes to the surrounding environment if it doesn't benefit them more or less directly.

Re: A Postmortem of a Startup

#19
post #13

well written. I think your fatal mistake even though you folks are smart was not understanding the complete value chain of your business. What I mean by understanding the economics of the value chain is you've to understand how your customers make money, how their customers make money & how their suppliers make money. From there - you can workout your value proposition - are you saving your customers money (means the…

I don't think the last paragraph is correct, many unicorns don't generate profit, yet are hugely successful by any other metric. In many cases, generating profit is actually undesirable for tax reasons.

Re: A Postmortem of a Startup

#20
Very thoughtful writing and great to see someone cut it early instead of continuing without a clear path.

> If I were to start a startup again, I’d take more time and be more intentional in talking to potential customers before needing to raise money.

From the outside, this pretty much hit the nail on the head.

Post reply on HN