Live data from Hacker News

Being Social Is About Being Private

kyrobeshay.com

11–12 of 12 posts

Re: Being Social Is About Being Private

#11
post #3

I think Apple's iMessage did this the best: read receipts are off by default, and "delivered" really just means it made it to the device, no more, no less. The new "Seen" aspect for Facebook messages is particularly sneaky, and I'm not a fan, but whatever. I expect people to respond in time eventually.

Since Facebook launched the "seen" feature, my friends have used Facebook messages significantly more often. Today's communication landscape is filled with tools that leave you uncertain if the recipients have seen or will ever see your message. Facebook messages will see more adoption because they remove that uncertainty.

Re: Being Social Is About Being Private

#12
I totally agree too, but can't help wondering how much different this is from the (relatively) old forms of social interactions in the online world. For example:

SMS has a receipt option. iPhone doesn't support it, but my old nokia does. I could easily see that my SMS was not only sent, but received by the other person.

Even on facebook, without any seen/read features (which I wasn't even aware of), I can send a message to someone, and then I might see that they posted some updates, added a friend or made a comment on mutual friend's post. Obviously they have seen my message then. Same would happen with email as long as I'm also connected to the same person on fb...

Chats / Skype / Online status - I tend to turn my chats off completely unless I need to, but when I'm online - people see it. If they see me online (e.g. google chat) they can assume that I got the email they sent me...

Don't get me wrong, I'm not justifying making things even more public. Quite the contrary. I wish there were better ways to maintain privacy and what people see about me and when. But the problem is very much already there.

Post reply on HN