Live data from Hacker News

Time Warp: Delayed-choice quantum erasure

drgblackwell.substack.com

11–20 of 82 posts

Re: Time Warp: Delayed-choice quantum erasure

#12

It would be nice if photons from the past could be captured to take pictures of millennia ago.

If you could use a wormhole to travel 50 million light years away from earth instantly, then look back at earth with a sufficiently powerful microscope, I believe you could observe the dinosaurs.

Re: Time Warp: Delayed-choice quantum erasure

#13

It would be nice if photons from the past could be captured to take pictures of millennia ago.

If you could use a wormhole to travel 50 million light years away from earth instantly, then look back at earth with a sufficiently powerful microscope, I believe you could observe the dinosaurs.

50 million light years would not get you light from 65+ million years ago.

Re: Time Warp: Delayed-choice quantum erasure

#14

It would be nice if photons from the past could be captured to take pictures of millennia ago.

If you could use a wormhole to travel 50 million light years away from earth instantly, then look back at earth with a sufficiently powerful microscope, I believe you could observe the dinosaurs.

There is this sci-fi book about this, but I forgot name/author. In the book a wormhole end can be positioned anywhere in space and time history. The tech starts as an ITER-like project and then becomes available in mainstream products, and all the dirty secrets of mankind come to light.

Re: Time Warp: Delayed-choice quantum erasure

#15

It would be nice if photons from the past could be captured to take pictures of millennia ago.

It "can" be done. Some photons leaving the earth a thousand years ago. Bouncing off a mirror in some distant planet and allowing us to see two thousand years into the past

Re: Time Warp: Delayed-choice quantum erasure

#16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you could use a wormhole to travel 50 million light years away from earth instantly, then look back at earth with a sufficiently powerful microscope, I believe you could observe the dinosaurs.

50 million light years would not get you light from 65+ million years ago.

Imagine seeing the exact point in time the asteroid hit!

Re: Time Warp: Delayed-choice quantum erasure

#17
I appreciate this article, as I agree with the author that the delayed-choice quantum eraser is a misnomer due to ignoring what we now know of quantum states. It's really frustrating learning modern quantum mechanics but then reading about the delayed-choice quantum eraser making conclusions from an older understanding.

However, I still haven't seen anyone do the math about it. It shouldn't be too hard to keep track of a photon's state through Kim et al.'s experiment, and I think it would be clearer than relying on words alone (as done by the author here). I have attempted this myself, but I am particularly terrible at quantum optics. If anyone has seen such a derivation before please let me know.

Re: Time Warp: Delayed-choice quantum erasure

#19

It would be nice if photons from the past could be captured to take pictures of millennia ago.

If you could use a wormhole to travel 50 million light years away from earth instantly, then look back at earth with a sufficiently powerful microscope, I believe you could observe the dinosaurs.

The photons would be so spread out that you'd need a telescope with a primary optic bigger than anything else in the universe. And even then, you'd struggle to capture enough to have any meaningful information.

Re: Time Warp: Delayed-choice quantum erasure

#20

I am I crazy or do Feynman diagrams not explicitly show interactions of particles moving back in time?

Yes they do and that is the secret to the wave-particle duality manifested in the double-slit experiment. Information from future completely illuminates (pi) the paradox.
Post reply on HN