Live data from Hacker News

Visualizing data is an art

perthirtysix.com

11–20 of 64 posts

Re: Visualizing data is an art

#11
No, it's not an Art.

I get that people use the word art as "difficult", "obscure" or "intangible" but...

Art is about self-expression, evoking emotions, and open interpretation. Design is about problem-solving, functionality, and clear communication.

Clearly DataViz is Design.

Re: Visualizing data is an art

#12
I've grown out of being impressed by flashy and difficult to understand data visualizations. I'm much more impressed by novel insight, clearly presented, in familiar ways.

Re: Visualizing data is an art

#13

No, it's not an Art. I get that people use the word art as "difficult", "obscure" or "intangible" but... Art is about self-expression, evoking emotions, and open interpretation. Design is about problem-solving, functionality, and clear communication. Clearly DataViz is Design.

I don't see art and design as mutually exclusive. I also don't think that data viz is exclusively about functionality.

Take a project like this: https://www.dear-data.com/theproject... this is clearly data visualization and, to me, quite evocative. These visualizations aren't designed for clarity and they don't need to be, that wasn't the goal.

Re: Visualizing data is an art

#14

No, it's not an Art. I get that people use the word art as "difficult", "obscure" or "intangible" but... Art is about self-expression, evoking emotions, and open interpretation. Design is about problem-solving, functionality, and clear communication. Clearly DataViz is Design.

data Viz for it's own sake might be design - in real applications, you always have a story you're trying to tell - and it doesn't go away just because you're not consciously aware of it.

Re: Visualizing data is an art

#15
post #12

I've grown out of being impressed by flashy and difficult to understand data visualizations. I'm much more impressed by novel insight, clearly presented, in familiar ways.

I'd call what you describe as impressive, art.

Flashy trashy is just crap. Some might call it art but then again everything is art these days.

Re: Visualizing data is an art

#16

No, it's not an Art. I get that people use the word art as "difficult", "obscure" or "intangible" but... Art is about self-expression, evoking emotions, and open interpretation. Design is about problem-solving, functionality, and clear communication. Clearly DataViz is Design.

Art as in craft/field! "State of the Art" is a phrase that refers to what is possible within a domain. There is also the implication that it takes judgement, maybe even an artistic sensibility. This is in opposition to a strain of thought within data viz from the Business Intelligence/Analytics side of the field that has succumbed to the MBA/Process gospel that preaches Repeatable Process and the siren song of good data visualization without using your brain!

Is Design an Art?

Re: Visualizing data is an art

#18

No, it's not an Art. I get that people use the word art as "difficult", "obscure" or "intangible" but... Art is about self-expression, evoking emotions, and open interpretation. Design is about problem-solving, functionality, and clear communication. Clearly DataViz is Design.

> Art is about self-expression, evoking emotions, and open interpretation

Art is about these things, but is also about many other things. And art can be clear in its intentions, leaving little to interpret.

What is the purpose of data visualization? Often to evoke emotions and to help someone not familiar with the data understand how to interpret it.

The people who accomplish this most effectively understand that the point isn't just to force data points into a visual form. If it were so simple, more people would be good at it (they aren't).

> Clearly DataViz is Design

I don't understand this sentence. I'm not trying to be difficult, but if DataViz is Design, what is Design?

Re: Visualizing data is an art

#19
post #15
post #12

I've grown out of being impressed by flashy and difficult to understand data visualizations. I'm much more impressed by novel insight, clearly presented, in familiar ways.

I'd call what you describe as impressive, art. Flashy trashy is just crap. Some might call it art but then again everything is art these days.

The greatest form of art is the discussion on whether something is art or not.

When you see a broken toilet sitting in an art gallery selling for 5 million dollars and someone thinks "I could do that, this is stupid", they have completely missed the point. The art is not the broken toilet, the art is selling it for 5 million dollars - which is something the complaining person definitly cannot do. That's the art.

Post reply on HN