Live data from Hacker News

Waymo to test its autonomous driving technology in over 10 new cities

reuters.com

11–20 of 138 posts

Re: Waymo to test its autonomous driving technology in over 10 new cities

#11

I wonder if the waymo solution is very vehicle specific or if it could be easily applied to say, a 10~12 person van that could accommodate a wheelchair? It would be interesting to design a transit system around 4~5 times as many vehicles with higher interval or more responsive pathing with something like pick up kiosks.

Are you... is this the micro-bus?

Re: Waymo to test its autonomous driving technology in over 10 new cities

#12

"In addition to ongoing trips to Truckee, Michigan's Upper Peninsula, Upstate New York and Tokyo, the expansion includes testing in San Diego and Las Vegas, with more cities yet to be announced." Pitching my own book here, but I think Jackson Hole would be a great place for Waymo. It's clearly delineated, has basically no freeway driving, affluent residents and a constant influx of tourists for brand building. The on…

I imagine they'll need a ton of testing and adjustments for driving in snow for all the conditions the car needs to detect and plan around, like the wheels slipping, or the car as a whole sliding down a hill. This is probably a separate effort from mapping out a city, but then needs to be tested in the real world. I think Truckee and Tahoe offer this environment within reasonable driving distance to the main Waymo de…

They're testing in Upper Minnesota and upstate New York. Upstate New York contains the snowiest city in the US, Syracuse.

Re: Waymo to test its autonomous driving technology in over 10 new cities

#13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I imagine they'll need a ton of testing and adjustments for driving in snow for all the conditions the car needs to detect and plan around, like the wheels slipping, or the car as a whole sliding down a hill. This is probably a separate effort from mapping out a city, but then needs to be tested in the real world. I think Truckee and Tahoe offer this environment within reasonable driving distance to the main Waymo de…

They're testing in Upper Minnesota and upstate New York. Upstate New York contains the snowiest city in the US, Syracuse.

Ah, good point then!

Re: Waymo to test its autonomous driving technology in over 10 new cities

#16

I wonder if the waymo solution is very vehicle specific or if it could be easily applied to say, a 10~12 person van that could accommodate a wheelchair? It would be interesting to design a transit system around 4~5 times as many vehicles with higher interval or more responsive pathing with something like pick up kiosks.

Self-driving makes the most economic sense when fewer people are in a vehicle. With a large van or bus, the cost of the human driver is split between more passengers. Also van or bus service is less compelling to individuals, as it makes them beholden to bus stop locations and schedules instead of picking them up and dropping them off when and where they want.

Adding support for wheelchairs introduces new failure modes that would require more software and/or human intervention. For example: Wheelchairs need to be strapped down for safety, and not all wheelchair users can do this themselves.

Re: Waymo to test its autonomous driving technology in over 10 new cities

#17
post #16

I wonder if the waymo solution is very vehicle specific or if it could be easily applied to say, a 10~12 person van that could accommodate a wheelchair? It would be interesting to design a transit system around 4~5 times as many vehicles with higher interval or more responsive pathing with something like pick up kiosks.

Self-driving makes the most economic sense when fewer people are in a vehicle. With a large van or bus, the cost of the human driver is split between more passengers. Also van or bus service is less compelling to individuals, as it makes them beholden to bus stop locations and schedules instead of picking them up and dropping them off when and where they want. Adding support for wheelchairs introduces new failure mod…

> With a large van or bus, the cost of the human driver is split between more passengers

It's also increased in that one must manage the passengers.

Re: Waymo to test its autonomous driving technology in over 10 new cities

#18
post #9

"In addition to ongoing trips to Truckee, Michigan's Upper Peninsula, Upstate New York and Tokyo, the expansion includes testing in San Diego and Las Vegas, with more cities yet to be announced." Pitching my own book here, but I think Jackson Hole would be a great place for Waymo. It's clearly delineated, has basically no freeway driving, affluent residents and a constant influx of tourists for brand building. The on…

> think Jackson Hole would be a great place for Waymo billionaire class wouldn’t be too happy with getting beta tested on raw tech. They will push back because “NIMBYism” runs deep.

> they will push back because “NIMBYism” runs deep

Waymo is being adopted in wealthy areas first. To the extent there is NIMBY sentiment, it's towards rideshare drivers. (Also, billionaires probably wouldn't be taking Waymo. If their properties aren't fly in they're driving themselves.)

Re: Waymo to test its autonomous driving technology in over 10 new cities

#19
post #5

When will this be rolled out to everywhere else?

In 2024 it had $365 million in revenue but $1.13 billion expenses.

I love that you included numbers, but that is for all of Alphabet's "other bets" which includes Waymo, so it's not entirely Waymo. It still helps give ballpark figures though.

Re: Waymo to test its autonomous driving technology in over 10 new cities

#20
I'm convinced that Waymo will quietly continue to roll out self driving taxi's to ever increasing areas in "beta" until one day they're covering a significant percentage of the most profitable areas to be a taxi in.

Instead of trying for universal self driving, they're going to prioritise being self driving taxi's for the most profitable areas.

Post reply on HN