Live data from Hacker News

Sparrow for Windows was just a few weeks away

everydaypanos.com

11–20 of 72 posts

Re: Sparrow for Windows was just a few weeks away

#11
Who owns this code ? Where you paid to develop this code ? If the OP was paid, his code belongs to google. In anycase a copyright will most likely apply to the user interface if it is a copycat of the Mac sparrow app.

If the OP manage to change it and eventually simplify it to make it significntly different, than the copyright won't hold and you own it as the author. The OP may then create his own brand. He should create his own app if the code doesn't belong to goggle.

I would suggest to make it a payed app, twice the price than Sparrow, and use the earned money to develop android, iOS and iMac version. If google offer to hire him, then request that the code is open source. Maybe Microsoft will have an offer to make too.

Of course Panos could also provide the app for free but he needs to earn a fair money for his work and for a living if we want him to continue and sustain the brand. Maybe another company could make an offer like Canonical for instance.

Re: Sparrow for Windows was just a few weeks away

#12
post #4

Open-source it. If they're really abandoning the product but actually care about improving the status of e-mail clients they won't send you a C&D. If they don't care about that as much as they care about preventing unauthorized use of their code, then everyone loses. But you can't know what'll happen unless you take action.

They were bought by Google, why would Google do that..?

Re: Sparrow for Windows was just a few weeks away

#13
post #4

Open-source it. If they're really abandoning the product but actually care about improving the status of e-mail clients they won't send you a C&D. If they don't care about that as much as they care about preventing unauthorized use of their code, then everyone loses. But you can't know what'll happen unless you take action.

They were bought by Google, why would Google do that..?

I don't know but it wouldn't be unprecedented. For example, Google open-sourced etherpad when they bought the company (mainly for the talent rather than the product).

Re: Sparrow for Windows was just a few weeks away

#14

Since hearing that Thunderbird is going to start collecting dust, I've been looking for a decent Windows client and was wishing Sparrow worked on Windows. So this makes me even more sad. I wish Google would do the right thing and open-source it like they did with Etherpad.

I've been using Postbox, and I couldn't be happier with it.

Re: Sparrow for Windows was just a few weeks away

#15
post #4

Open-source it. If they're really abandoning the product but actually care about improving the status of e-mail clients they won't send you a C&D. If they don't care about that as much as they care about preventing unauthorized use of their code, then everyone loses. But you can't know what'll happen unless you take action.

They were bought by Google, why would Google do that..?

They did it with reMail (http://www.remail.com/), too.

Re: Sparrow for Windows was just a few weeks away

#17

dude. kickstarter. go. Sparrow is one of the few reasons I stick with using a mac, and am somewhat fearful of taking another job using windows again. I even tried having outlook configured in a mode to look more sparrow-ish to realize it didn't work without a real "sparrow" experience.

I imagine there will be something similar coming from Google in the future..

Re: Sparrow for Windows was just a few weeks away

#18

dude. kickstarter. go. Sparrow is one of the few reasons I stick with using a mac, and am somewhat fearful of taking another job using windows again. I even tried having outlook configured in a mode to look more sparrow-ish to realize it didn't work without a real "sparrow" experience.

Dude is in Greece, so no Kickstarter for dude.

Re: Sparrow for Windows was just a few weeks away

#19

Since hearing that Thunderbird is going to start collecting dust, I've been looking for a decent Windows client and was wishing Sparrow worked on Windows. So this makes me even more sad. I wish Google would do the right thing and open-source it like they did with Etherpad.

Got the exact same problem. Actually using Windows Live Mail right now. Really hoping Panos finishes it and releases it!

Re: Sparrow for Windows was just a few weeks away

#20
post #4

Open-source it. If they're really abandoning the product but actually care about improving the status of e-mail clients they won't send you a C&D. If they don't care about that as much as they care about preventing unauthorized use of their code, then everyone loses. But you can't know what'll happen unless you take action.

Some parts already are Open Sourced. Mainly helper libs tho ( https://github.com/everydaypanos/Peacock ).
Post reply on HN