Live data from Hacker News

Sixteen U.S. states still ban community-owned broadband networks

techdirt.com

11–20 of 170 posts

Re: Sixteen U.S. states still ban community-owned broadband networks

#13

Once space-based broadband Internet becomes widely available, I predict shortsighted ISPs will join the ranks of Kodak and Blockbuster.

This has a "Bitcoin will solve finance" feel to it. Not to be super dismissive, but there's just as much likelihood it will help as it won't. But in your corner: It's true that right now space-based deployment of broadband will provide broadband in locations where it's not currently available - perhaps spurring competition. It's also probably true that space-based broadband will be able to compete directly with urban…

TV made radio irrelevant, the internet made TV irrelevant. Both still exists but as money-losing mass manipulation tools

Re: Sixteen U.S. states still ban community-owned broadband networks

#16
post #3

Once space-based broadband Internet becomes widely available, I predict shortsighted ISPs will join the ranks of Kodak and Blockbuster.

If that happens, wouldn't it be potentially worse than the current situation? Surely your local neighborhood isn't going to deploy its own dedicated satellite constellation. If/when satelite broadband becomes widespread, it will likely be consolidated and provided by 1 provider (maybe 2?) which might end up resulting in higher costs for everyone all around.

It is very hard for me to imagine space-based internet ever being able to be competitive financially with an earth-based option outside of special circumstances.

Re: Sixteen U.S. states still ban community-owned broadband networks

#18

Once space-based broadband Internet becomes widely available, I predict shortsighted ISPs will join the ranks of Kodak and Blockbuster.

Im extremely jealous of this techno optimism perspective. In my view at no point has there been a decrease in monopolisation or increase in democratisation since the hopeful cybernetic 90's, so i just don't see this as good, more like some Tyrell or state owned corporate almost fascist dystopia where everything is owned and censored by the few, and just because it's "awesome and space based" only adds to the exclusivity. It's already leaked Musk is working for the US military, so it isn't some benevolent, utilitarian or even broad scaled project it's a project for world domination and enslavement.

Re: Sixteen U.S. states still ban community-owned broadband networks

#20

Once space-based broadband Internet becomes widely available, I predict shortsighted ISPs will join the ranks of Kodak and Blockbuster.

Is the total possible bandwidth available on these even comparable to optical fibers?

Pretty obviously not, theoretically you could have tens of terrabits per fibre core. The limiting factor is the electronics at either end.
Post reply on HN