Live data from Hacker News

Beautiful Windows 8 concept

dribbble.com

11–20 of 54 posts

Re: Beautiful Windows 8 concept

#11
post #8

Why doesn't Desktop Mode look like this already?. Everyone else seems to understand that this is the logical look to achieve. Even Git for windows and Zune have this skin already. edit: github not git, my bad.

Nitpicky, I know, but that's Github for Windows. Git is not the same as Github, folks.

Re: Beautiful Windows 8 concept

#14
post #7

Really nice, though it begs the question; seeing as you can't meaningfully affect Windows 8's design without joining Microsoft on the relevant team(s), why not apply your design skills to the Linux desktop, either Gnome or KDE (I don't know which is more popular as I'm not really a Linux user). Improving the Linux GUI's presentation is always a good thing in terms of improving end-user adoption.

Would be a great theme for Ubuntu or something similar, indeed. Ps, I'm not the designer - just thought of this when I saw the Windows 8 logo concept on HN

Re: Beautiful Windows 8 concept

#15
post #7

Really nice, though it begs the question; seeing as you can't meaningfully affect Windows 8's design without joining Microsoft on the relevant team(s), why not apply your design skills to the Linux desktop, either Gnome or KDE (I don't know which is more popular as I'm not really a Linux user). Improving the Linux GUI's presentation is always a good thing in terms of improving end-user adoption.

Gnome is probably more popular. My believe is that KDE is much more superior, at least on the surface. KDE is highly skinable, I'd say Gnome is too. There are thousands of various themes available and this one would be lost between them. Windows is skinable as well, and you have hundreds and thousands of themes for it as well.

So you can do this as a hobby, mostly for a portfolio.

Re: Beautiful Windows 8 concept

#16

I saw this a few months ago (i cant remember where) and i'm sure there were a whole load more screenshots to go with it. While i'd love to see this and it is undeniably beautiful, its not really what i'd call a practical solution. This makes me wonder, is it only beautiful because its a concept? It only looks so good because its free from practical restriction, what would it look like if it was made into a real world…

http://www.theverge.com/2012/2/24/2822891/windows-desktop-ui...

This is where I saw it first too, thanks for posting the link - couldn't remember where, just knew it was on Dribbble too. A lot more other screenshots on The Verge.

Re: Beautiful Windows 8 concept

#17
post #7

Really nice, though it begs the question; seeing as you can't meaningfully affect Windows 8's design without joining Microsoft on the relevant team(s), why not apply your design skills to the Linux desktop, either Gnome or KDE (I don't know which is more popular as I'm not really a Linux user). Improving the Linux GUI's presentation is always a good thing in terms of improving end-user adoption.

Being a Windows mockup doesn't mean Gnome or KDE can't take inspiration from it. :)

Actually when this was first made (a few months ago) it was just an experiment to see how Metro styles and concepts could be applied to the desktop. Back then the Win8 builds were still all using Aero and there was no hint of a new style, so in retrospect it got quite a few things right.

Re: Beautiful Windows 8 concept

#19

I saw this a few months ago (i cant remember where) and i'm sure there were a whole load more screenshots to go with it. While i'd love to see this and it is undeniably beautiful, its not really what i'd call a practical solution. This makes me wonder, is it only beautiful because its a concept? It only looks so good because its free from practical restriction, what would it look like if it was made into a real world…

> This also makes me ask, is the only way to radically change UI to come up with a completely new from scratch paradigm, and if so, is this why we have metro?

Surely, quite a lot of time a design can be tweaked in its current version to make some great changes which drastically improve upon the usability. But on the contrary I think that Windows has reached a stage where some minor tweaks in its current incarnation won't make a lot of difference. It can only be optimized not radically improved until it is completely though from bottom up.

You might like to read about the concept of "Local Maximum"[1] on 52 weeks of UX. Here's a excerpt from the post.

Do you ever feel that your design has become stale and that despite your making lots of little changes to it over time without any big overhaul there is just no way to drastically improve it? If so you’ve probably hit what Andrew Chen calls the “Local Maximum”.

[1]http://52weeksofux.com/post/694598769/the-local-maximum

Post reply on HN