Live data from Hacker News

'Agua, Agua'

altaonline.com

11–20 of 77 posts

Re: 'Agua, Agua'

#11
post #10
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You risk heart attack even if you are in water only diet (without salts and potassium) for longer periods of time (several weeks).

Stupid question, but if stuck in the desert you can suck on some rock to recoup some lost minerals, no? I guess like any deer we'd immediately recognise (and love) the taste of rock salt

[deleted]

Re: 'Agua, Agua'

#12

I think it's pretty stupid to challenge yourself in ways that are guaranteed to harm your body in some way, even if the harm is temporary.

Nobody should do anything ever.

Re: 'Agua, Agua'

#13
post #10
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You risk heart attack even if you are in water only diet (without salts and potassium) for longer periods of time (several weeks).

Stupid question, but if stuck in the desert you can suck on some rock to recoup some lost minerals, no? I guess like any deer we'd immediately recognise (and love) the taste of rock salt

[deleted]

Re: 'Agua, Agua'

#14
post #10
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You risk heart attack even if you are in water only diet (without salts and potassium) for longer periods of time (several weeks).

Stupid question, but if stuck in the desert you can suck on some rock to recoup some lost minerals, no? I guess like any deer we'd immediately recognise (and love) the taste of rock salt

I've got to imagine this would mess with our ability to cool ourselves even if it gave us more water retention.

Re: 'Agua, Agua'

#15
post #7

I think it's pretty stupid to challenge yourself in ways that are guaranteed to harm your body in some way, even if the harm is temporary.

You offer criticism of a spiritual practice you do not understand.

He offers criticism based upon a biological outcome to a spiritual practice, he does not need to understand to declare the outcome stupid. The cultural practices are protected from criticism stuff does not fly- less all insanity of the past comes back crawling from the cracks. Cant criticise witch burnings as they are a "cultural" practice..

Re: 'Agua, Agua'

#16
post #3

Tendai "Marathon monks" in mount Hiei finish 1,000-day kaihōgyō with 9-day period without food, water, and sleep but they have to walk only 400m in those last 9-days. Only 46 men have finished. If I remember correctly the 9-day period was shortened to something like 6 or 7 days, because too many of them died.

I'm willing to bet that whomever originally came up with the 'auspicious' 9 days never did it themselves.

Re: 'Agua, Agua'

#18
post #7

I think it's pretty stupid to challenge yourself in ways that are guaranteed to harm your body in some way, even if the harm is temporary.

You offer criticism of a spiritual practice you do not understand.

[deleted]

Re: 'Agua, Agua'

#19
post #7

I think it's pretty stupid to challenge yourself in ways that are guaranteed to harm your body in some way, even if the harm is temporary.

You offer criticism of a spiritual practice you do not understand.

Human sacrifice, genital mutilation and various forms of slavery have all been excused as a 'spiritual practice'. "Understanding" will not make me go 'oh, sure...now your destructive practice makes total sense...carry on'. Get over yourself.

Re: 'Agua, Agua'

#20
post #3

Tendai "Marathon monks" in mount Hiei finish 1,000-day kaihōgyō with 9-day period without food, water, and sleep but they have to walk only 400m in those last 9-days. Only 46 men have finished. If I remember correctly the 9-day period was shortened to something like 6 or 7 days, because too many of them died.

I'm willing to bet that whomever originally came up with the 'auspicious' 9 days never did it themselves.

Since it seems like a group that already practices and values feats of fasting and endurance it's probably most likely that it commemorates a single particularly notable fast attributed to a specific individual in the community's history. It's possible that that individual didn't actually succeed and it was based on a myth. But I seriously doubt some guy decided one day to try to trick his peers into doing a brutal fast that had never been done.
Post reply on HN