Live data from Hacker News

Do I Regret Being 'Just' a Software Engineer?

jacky.wtf

11–20 of 62 posts

Re: Do I Regret Being 'Just' a Software Engineer?

#11

Tech is much like the fission bomb. Perhaps necessary, but the industry doesn't stop there. It must create bigger. Returns, investment, power, being a have and not a have not. "Dr. Oppenheimer, when did your strong moral convictions develop with respect to the hydrogen bomb?" "When it became clear to me that we would use whatever weapon we had."

Yeah. I only hesitate when we see people more eager to use things to exacerbate the harms of the world using technology. It sucks because we, as an industry, seem to only focus on the history of business gains and not on the sociological impact of said gains (the introduction of the smartphone and how that played into how people connect - or even what _was_ the first smartphone).

I think of worthwhile software projects as stools with three legs: The business opportunity, the interesting technical problem, and the social/ethical issues. They all need to be good in order to have an acceptable product, IMO.

Unfortunately, whenever you read an article about a new technology or read an interview of a founder or something, they spend all their time talking about the first two, and either ignore or give passing lip service to the third one. Even look at HN discussions. Few engineers here really care about the ethics of what they are working on. It's just "is it cool technology?" and (sometimes) "does it make money?" You ask someone if they are working on something good for the world and they look at you like you have an antler growing out of your head. "Yes, I'm making the Torment Nexus, but it uses blockchain and LLMs and it's written in Rust. It's written in RUST!"

Re: Do I Regret Being 'Just' a Software Engineer?

#12
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think woodworking is also a popular alternative, especially if you've always felt like ten fingers was too many.

so is abandoning everything for a farm raising goats.

https://www.goatops.com ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26336880 )

Re: Do I Regret Being 'Just' a Software Engineer?

#13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah. I only hesitate when we see people more eager to use things to exacerbate the harms of the world using technology. It sucks because we, as an industry, seem to only focus on the history of business gains and not on the sociological impact of said gains (the introduction of the smartphone and how that played into how people connect - or even what _was_ the first smartphone).

I think of worthwhile software projects as stools with three legs: The business opportunity, the interesting technical problem, and the social/ethical issues. They all need to be good in order to have an acceptable product, IMO. Unfortunately, whenever you read an article about a new technology or read an interview of a founder or something, they spend all their time talking about the first two, and either ignore or…

I think a lot of it stems from a misguided sort of "yes I'm inventing the torment nexus, but it will never be used on me, because I'm the inventor"

Or perhaps "If it isn't me inventing the torment nexus, then someone else will"

Either way, I wish people cared more about how their inventions would be used

Re: Do I Regret Being 'Just' a Software Engineer?

#14
post #3

Do what everyone else does. Get into craft beer or coffee as a hobby and slip into a deep depression. It’s well documented.

I think woodworking is also a popular alternative, especially if you've always felt like ten fingers was too many.

I know a lot of woodworkers. It must be that it’s a largely solitary hobby where you get to build very very concrete and useful things that us “not really an engineer” software folks try to compensate for. Me included

Re: Do I Regret Being 'Just' a Software Engineer?

#15

Tech is much like the fission bomb. Perhaps necessary, but the industry doesn't stop there. It must create bigger. Returns, investment, power, being a have and not a have not. "Dr. Oppenheimer, when did your strong moral convictions develop with respect to the hydrogen bomb?" "When it became clear to me that we would use whatever weapon we had."

Yeah. I only hesitate when we see people more eager to use things to exacerbate the harms of the world using technology. It sucks because we, as an industry, seem to only focus on the history of business gains and not on the sociological impact of said gains (the introduction of the smartphone and how that played into how people connect - or even what _was_ the first smartphone).

Social media is incredibly destructive, yet look at all the money we've made from it. Probably one in 5 people believed in "connecting the world"...

Re: Do I Regret Being 'Just' a Software Engineer?

#20
> get a Dell PC, ones I've read online that were serviceable

When I "repaired" a Dell PC, I destroyed the machine.

Dell power-supplies looked like standard PC power supplies; they connected to the motherboard using the same Molex plug. But Dell's Molex connector wasn't wired the same as normal ones. Dell power supplies only worked with Dell motherboards, and vice-versa.

Things may have changed, but that experience blew away my illusions about Dells being repairable.

Post reply on HN