Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft Bans Linux/Android Dual-Booting on Windows 8 ARM Devices

dailytech.com

11–20 of 137 posts

Re: Microsoft Bans Linux/Android Dual-Booting on Windows 8 ARM Devices

#11
post #9

We've yet to see any mobile device where running another OS than the bundled one have been anything but a nightmare. This is done everywhere, android manufacturers constantly try to lock users in their own android shell, not to mention apple. These devices are not multipurpose devices, they are built for a specific purpose and tailormade for that and nothing else. It is not in any sense equivalent to desktop/laptop-c…

Exception: HP Touchpad. ICS runs great on it.

Re: Microsoft Bans Linux/Android Dual-Booting on Windows 8 ARM Devices

#12
post #9

We've yet to see any mobile device where running another OS than the bundled one have been anything but a nightmare. This is done everywhere, android manufacturers constantly try to lock users in their own android shell, not to mention apple. These devices are not multipurpose devices, they are built for a specific purpose and tailormade for that and nothing else. It is not in any sense equivalent to desktop/laptop-c…

>This is done everywhere, android manufacturers constantly try to lock users in their own android shell, not to mention apple.

And people still jailbreak/root their devices for numerous reasons. If you buy something, you should be able to do what you want with it. Just because it's designed for one thing doesn't mean it can't do others.

Re: Microsoft Bans Linux/Android Dual-Booting on Windows 8 ARM Devices

#17
post #9

We've yet to see any mobile device where running another OS than the bundled one have been anything but a nightmare. This is done everywhere, android manufacturers constantly try to lock users in their own android shell, not to mention apple. These devices are not multipurpose devices, they are built for a specific purpose and tailormade for that and nothing else. It is not in any sense equivalent to desktop/laptop-c…

I strongly disagree.

>> "These devices are not multipurpose devices".

These devices have chips which can run any algorithm you write. They are not hammers, or even calculators. They are computers. They also have GPS, motion sensors, cameras, and microphones. They are multipurpose enough to make phone calls, play games, run maps, and even power satellites: http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/station/main/spheres_smart...

>> Since Microsoft have expressed that secure boot must be optional on x86 it is quite easy to justify this rationally...

Why does doing the right thing in once place give them license to do the wrong thing in another?

I appreciate the security value of secure boot, but ONLY as far as its purpose is to serve the customer. Which means the customer must be able to disable it.

Re: Microsoft Bans Linux/Android Dual-Booting on Windows 8 ARM Devices

#18
post #9

We've yet to see any mobile device where running another OS than the bundled one have been anything but a nightmare. This is done everywhere, android manufacturers constantly try to lock users in their own android shell, not to mention apple. These devices are not multipurpose devices, they are built for a specific purpose and tailormade for that and nothing else. It is not in any sense equivalent to desktop/laptop-c…

Exception: HP Touchpad. ICS runs great on it.

I've read that the Nokia N9 also does a good job of running ICS.

Other counter examples: Boot2Gecko (runs well & generally demoed on a Samsung Galaxy S2), Ubuntu for Android, ASUS Transformers running various Linux distributions, ...

Re: Microsoft Bans Linux/Android Dual-Booting on Windows 8 ARM Devices

#19
post #7

Like iOS. Why the shock headline?

I would love to see an open bootloader for iDevices. However, I do think that there is a difference between Apple, a company who makes their own hardware and have chosen this strategy, and Microsoft, a company who tries to impose their strategy on others (device makers).
Post reply on HN