Live data from Hacker News

Dear Startups, Lobster is the new Comic Sans

5in5nyc.com

11–20 of 68 posts

Re: Dear Startups, Lobster is the new Comic Sans

#11
post #4

Lobster is a nice, versatile, _trendy_ typeface. What's wrong with that?

Indeed - it is a very nice font. Unfortunately we're ALL using it in our projects, and it can make projects look lazy or "me too".

It's sad, because it was a very nice font, but it's just overused.

Re: Dear Startups, Lobster is the new Comic Sans

#12

... said the company with the awful trying-to-be-hip design.

Looks like the most simplest wordpress template to me. I'd appreciate any thought over no thought when it comes to design.

Hahaha, touche. The 5in5NYC design needs some serious work :) It's absolutely on my todo.

Re: Dear Startups, Lobster is the new Comic Sans

#13
post #7
post #4

Lobster is a nice, versatile, _trendy_ typeface. What's wrong with that?

Nothing at all, and there was nothing wrong with Comic Sans either. However it drives my friends who aspire to be designers into frothing fits of rage. It was explained to me this way, "Chuck lets say that bubble sorts and bloom filters were these versatile algorithms that worked really well on a few things, but a bunch of cut-n-paste programmers started using them for every program they wrote, hello world with a bub…

I think the larger point there is "does any of that matter"? I don't think it does. It's possible to be a lazy programmer and a lazy designer and still be entirely successful. Understandable that it irritates programmers and designers, but it's a fact of life.

Re: Dear Startups, Lobster is the new Comic Sans

#15
Oy. Comic Sans isn't problematic because everyone uses it, it's problematic because it's a bad font. The kerning alone is reason enough not to use it.

http://www.kadavy.net/blog/posts/why-you-hate-comic-sans/

By this author's logic we should all stop using Helvetica, too - it's way too common.

Re: Dear Startups, Lobster is the new Comic Sans

#16

We will look back at our designs and sites years from now and go... "What happened to 90% of those sites?" :)

http://www.killersites.com/killerSites/ And yet, in its time, this was the shit. Let's pour one out for the single-pixel GIF ...

Not to mention 'blockquote' for horizontal padding and hundred other dirty little tricks.

I couldn't help noticing, though, that the page loaded wicked fast. Can't say I would mind it if more of the web was still that efficient.

Re: Dear Startups, Lobster is the new Comic Sans

#17

The problem is its overuse, not it's qualities as a typeface. Comic Sans is not a bad typeface, it was merely overused and became a cliche. Lobster is well down that same path.

Comic Sans is a terrible typeface. Frequency of use has nothing to do with it.

Re: Dear Startups, Lobster is the new Comic Sans

#18
Lobster may be an overused font of the moment, but it doesn't have the pedigree of Comic Sans. Not even close.

Once Lobster has shown up consistently on PTA meeting itineraries, junior high pep-rally announcements and yard-sale flyers for about 15 years then maybe that font will be able to compare itself to Comic Sans.

Re: Dear Startups, Lobster is the new Comic Sans

#19

Oy. Comic Sans isn't problematic because everyone uses it, it's problematic because it's a bad font. The kerning alone is reason enough not to use it. http://www.kadavy.net/blog/posts/why-you-hate-comic-sans/ By this author's logic we should all stop using Helvetica, too - it's way too common.

I agree that Lobster is a better font than comic sans, but both fonts have particular uses, and they both have a signature look that people recognize.

Helvetica, in my opinion, is a fantastic utility. It gets out of the way, and only those who know to look for it notice it.

Re: Dear Startups, Lobster is the new Comic Sans

#20
post #4

Lobster is a nice, versatile, _trendy_ typeface. What's wrong with that?

Indeed - it is a very nice font. Unfortunately we're ALL using it in our projects, and it can make projects look lazy or "me too". It's sad, because it was a very nice font, but it's just overused.

Nice fonts should be used as often as possible. I would be happy if more people used Lobster, because it's nice!
Post reply on HN